Good Morning
Good Morning
LifestyleLong Island Events

Antiques, collectibles appraised for free by experts at annual Islip fair

A quail feathered hat could be one of

A quail feathered hat could be one of the finds this year at the Antique, Vintage and Collectibles Show at Sagtikos Manor in West Bay Shore. Credit: Daniel Goodrich

If you’ve seen the popular PBS “Antiques Roadshow,” you know the treasures — prized for their value or purely sentimental — that can lurk in attics and basements. The Islip Arts Council has been hosting its annual antiques and collectibles fair for decades, offering patrons a place to shop for vintage finds or get something they already own evaluated.

About 50 vendors of everything from antique toys and hand- carved picture frames to rare coins and stamps display their wares June 10 on the grounds of Brookwood Hall, a circa 1902 neo-Georgian mansion that now houses the council and its museum.

A highlight of the fair is the appraisal table, presided over by certified art and antiques appraiser Ted Oberg of All American Auctions in Islip, along with a team of colleagues.

It’s a long-standing tradition that fair visitors can receive free on-the-spot verbal appraisals for items they bring with them.

“It’s like a treasure hunt — you never know what will show up,” Oberg says. Several years ago, fair visitor Gerard Cuff brought two paintings he’d inherited from his grandmother.

“I’m old-fashioned,” says Cuff, who lives in Babylon. “I didn’t like the style of those pictures — too abstract, and they’d just been gathering dust in my basement for years. Ted recognized that they’d been painted by an Italian impressionist, Vincenzo Irolli.” Fast forward a few months and they were sold at a Manhattan auction house for about $40,000 each, Cuff says.

“Another time, we found an original Tiffany lamp worth $20,000,” Oberg says. But there’s a value beyond dollar figures, too.

“We almost always find extraordinary things that are rich in history and nostalgia; sometimes we can bring joy to the owner, but sometimes it’s disappointment,” Oberg says. Like last year, when a fairgoer brought a beautiful Japanese Satsuma ware tea set that turned out to be a $100 reproduction — it wouldn’t fetch the thousands that the originals from centuries ago can bring.


WHEN | WHERE 10 a.m.-4 p.m. June 10, 50 Irish Lane, East Islip


INFO 631-224-5420,



WHEN | WHERE 9 a.m.-4 p.m. June 10 and June 24 (continues every other Saturday through Sept. 16) at Rogers Mansion Museum Complex, 17 Meeting House Lane, Southampton

INFO 631-283-2494,


This is the place for antique furniture — benches, chests, tables, chairs, etc. Also find jewelry, vintage clothing, glass, ceramics, artwork and collectibles — all scattered throughout the grounds, barn and consignment shop.


WHEN | WHERE 10 a.m.-4 p.m. June 18 (rain date June 25) at Sagtikos Manor, Montauk Highway, West Bay Shore

INFO 631-889-1166,

ADMISSION $3 (free younger than 12); $10 early-bird entry at 9 a.m.

This fair attracts about 30 vendors with a wide range of early-to mid-century specialties such as shabby chic linens and clothing, estate jewelry and watches. Also find plants, Depression glass, comic books, and odd bits of furniture for refinishing such as headboards.


WHEN | WHERE 10 a.m.-6 p.m. June 24 and 10 a.m.-4 p.m. June 25 at Bridgehampton Museum, 2368 Montauk Hwy., Bridgehampton

INFO 631-537-1088,

ADMISSION $5 (free ages 11 and younger)

Among the 50 vendors of furniture, paintings and assorted home accessories there is a collector of vintage cigarette cards that were given away with packs of cigarettes decades ago.

More Lifestyle