Good Afternoon
Good Afternoon

Lobster rolls, priced $19.50 to $40

The lobster roll at Artie's South Shore is

The lobster roll at Artie's South Shore is subtly flavored with tarragon. Credit: Timothy Fadek

Lobster rolls, a Long Island summer passion, don’t come cheap. And, as we found in a quick survey, prices can range widely.

A look at six Long Island lobster rolls yielded these numbers. Note that all of the places listed below use fresh, not frozen, lobster meat:

$19.50 at The Clam Bar in Amagansett
$19.95 at Artie’s  South Shore Fish & Grill in Island Park
$22 at Duryea’s Lobster Deck in Montauk
$25.95 at Legal Sea Foods in Huntington Station
$29.95 at Old Fields in Greenlawn
$40 at Silver’s in Southampton

Got a yen for one of these? Better count your clams first.

Latest reviews