TODAY'S PAPER
Overcast 27° Good Evening
Overcast 27° Good Evening
LifestyleRestaurants

Long Island restaurants that have lasted 50-plus years: Bigelow’s, Claudio’s, more

Fifty means gold.
And there are more than a score of Long Island restaurants that have struck it, reaching the age in a business where surviving beyond a year typically is enjoyed by less than half.
The reasons for longevity range from location and property ownership to family management and labor, from the quality of food to the loyalty of customers.
“The one big word is ‘consistency,’ ” said Otto Wittmeier, co-owner with his brother John, of the Modern Snack Bar in Aquebogue, which opens for its 67th year on April 18, 2017.
“We don’t seem to vary. We don’t wander off our footprint. And we have people who call to reserve their chicken potpie for Wednesday and Thursday lunch.” And the Wittmeiers emphasize local ingredients, from duckling to scallops.
Cliff Saunders III owns Cliff’s Elbow Room, established in Jamesport in 1958. He said that while the fare has changed a bit over the years, “most customers still don’t even look at the menu,” already knowing what they want.
Saunders’ grandparents owned a restaurant in Laurel in 1946 that eventually became Cliff’s Elbow Too. There’s also Cliff’s Rendezvous in Riverhead, which arrived in 1977. “It’s not just the local residents. People come from North Babylon, from Massapequa . . . some just to say ‘hi’ . . . it’s like a family.”
Among the older Nassau County restaurants is Louie’s in Port Washington, once Louie’s Shore, later Louie’s Oyster Bar & Grille, now Louie’s Grill & Liquors. “But it’s always Louie’s,” said co-owner Martin Picone. “It was owned by the [Zwerlein] family for 97 years.” Louie’s began as a barge and eventually became a dockside landmark.
“It’s an integral part of the community,” Picone said, and the site of many “family events . . . christenings, showers, weddings, bereavement — the whole life cycle.”
Here are a dozen Long Island restaurants that have entered their own gilded age.

Arturo’s (1961)

A 1961 photo of Arturo's in Floral Park
Photo Credit: Arturo's Restaurant

Arturo’s (246-04 Jericho Tpke., Floral Park): Arturo’s has reigned at the Nassau-Queens border since a postage stamp was 4 cents; a gallon of gasoline, 27 cents. The menu has undergone some changes since 1961, but the refined approach and service continue. Recommended: torta primavera, or many layered crepes with cured meats, cheeses and vegetables; meatballs marinara with shaved Parmesan cheese; rigatoni Siciliana; osso buco; zabaglione for two with strawberries and ice cream; and anything from the dessert cart. More info: 516-352-7418, arturorestaurant.com
 

Antonio D'Anna prepares the Rigatoni Arturo, at Arturo's
Photo Credit: Yvonne Albinowski

Antonio D'Anna prepares the Rigatoni Arturo, at Arturo's in Floral Park.

The popular branzino, as served at Arturo's Restaurant
Photo Credit: Arturo's/Yvonne Albinowski

The popular branzino, as served at Arturo's in Floral Park.

Bigelow’s (1939)

Photo from about 1955 -1956. Bigelow's Seafood in
Photo Credit: Bigelow's Seafood

Bigelow’s (79 N. Long Beach Rd., Rockville Centre): When Bigelow’s started frying in 1939, a new house cost about $3,800 and average annual income was $1,730. It remains a cash-only ultracasual destination for seafood, notably Ipswich clams, which Russ Bigelow was the first to fry on Long Island. Recommended: fried Ipswich, or whole belly clams; fried clam strips, smelts and whiting; fish and chips, made with either cod or flounder. More info: 516-678-3878, bigelows-rvc.com
 

ROCKVILLE CENTRE, NY: Monday, Oct. 20, 2008-- An
Photo Credit: NEWSDAY/Audrey C. Tiernan

An exterior view of Bigelow's in Rockville Centre. 

Bigelow's in Rockville Centre offers both clam strips
Photo Credit: Newsday/Rebecca Cooney

Bigelow's in Rockville Centre offers both clam strips and full Ipswitch Clams (with bellies, shown here) that they bread on-site just before frying.

Borrelli’s (1955)

A vintage postcard for Borrelli's in East Meadow
Photo Credit: Frank Borrelli

Borrelli’s (1580 Hempstead Tpke., East Meadow): Borrelli’s opened in 1955, “before the Meadowbrook Parkway,” said owner Frank Borrelli Jr., “and before chicken Parmigiana. We had veal Parmigiana.” The informal Italian spot expanded and updated the menu over the decades but remains a magnet for local diners as well as visitors to Jones Beach and Eisenhower Park. Recommended: lasagna, linguine with clam sauce, chicken Francaise. More info: 516-794-0190, borrellisrestaurant.com

Frank Borrelli, Borrelli's, East Meadow, Mar. 26, 2017.
Photo Credit: Yvonne Albinowski

Frank Borrelli, owner of Borrelli’s in East Meadow.

Zuppa di Pesce with shrimp, mussels, calamari, and
Photo Credit: Yvonne Albinowski

Zuppa di Pesce with shrimp, mussels, calamari, and scallops over linguine in a red clam sauce at Borrelli’s in East Meadow.

Casa Basso (1928)

A vintage postcard shows Casa Basso in Westhampton,
Photo Credit: Collection of Rebecca Cooney

Casa Basso (59 Montauk Hwy., Westhampton): The namesake restaurant of M.L. Basso opened in 1928. Thirty years later, it changed ownership and was renamed Rene’s Casa Basso. Since 1986, it has been known as just Casa Basso and has been run by Bejto Bracovic, also the executive chef. The castle-like structure always has been identified by the 12-foot-tall statues of dueling musketeers just outside. Recommended: lobster, any style; clams casino; roast Long Island duckling. More info: 631-288-1841, casabasso.net
 

Two large swordsmen stand at the entrance of
Photo Credit: Daniel Brennan

Two large swordsmen stand at the entrance of Casa Basso near the Old Montauk Highway in Westhampton. 

Veal Parmigiana has been a mainstay at Casa
Photo Credit: benjamin petit

Veal Parmigiana has been a mainstay at Casa Basso in Westhampton. 

Claudio’s (1870)

Claudio's Restaurant in 1904 when it was a
Photo Credit: Claudio's Restaurant

Claudio’s (111 Main St., Greenport): In 2012, the National Restaurant Association officially designated Claudio’s as the “oldest same-family-run restaurant” in the country. Manuel Claudio, a whaler, arrived on a Portuguese ship that docked in 1854. For 16 years, that whaling ship sailed from Greenport. By 1870, Claudio opened a tavern there. The fourth generation of Claudios is at work. Nearby are Claudio’s Clam Bar and self-service Crabby Jerry’s. Recommended: steamed lobster, lobster roll, local oysters. More info: 631-477-0627, claudios.com
 

Diners at Claudio's restaurant can dine in or
Photo Credit: Doug Young

At Claudio's in Greenport, dining can be done in or outside, looking out over the pier.

Claudio's Restaurant in Greenport serves lobsters in an
Photo Credit: Doug Young

Claudio's Restaurant in Greenport serves lobsters in an array of manners such as this baked, stuffed lobster. 

Cliff’s Elbow Room (1958)

The Elbow Room restaurant in 1959.
Photo Credit: Elbow Room

Cliff’s Elbow Room (1549 Main Rd., Jamesport): In the early 1950s, Cliff’s was known as a bar. Now, there are 14 tables at Cliff’s Elbow Room, and they fill quickly. This casual gathering place has been serving since the year of “Vertigo” and “Gigi.” The restaurant is a destination for its marinated porterhouse steak. The secret marinade has hints of garlic and soy. Recommended: all steaks, marinated or not; fried oysters; broiled bay scallops. More info: 631-722-3292, elbowroomli.com
 

The dining room of Cliff's Elbow Room, at
Photo Credit: Gordon M. Grant

The dining room of Cliff's Elbow Room in Jamesport.

Marinated Porterhouse steak, as served at Cliff's Elbow
Photo Credit: Gordon M. Grant

Marinated Porterhouse steak, as served at Cliff's Elbow Room in Jamesport.

The Jolly Fisherman & Steak House (1957)

The Jolly Fisherman & Steak House has been
Photo Credit: Bruce Gilbert

 The Jolly Fisherman & Steak House (25 Main St., Roslyn): Resisting mini-trends and sticking to fresh seafood and tender beef bridges decades. The waterside restaurant has been owned only by the Scheiner family since 1957. Steve Scheiner, whose grandparents were the original owners, said 65 percent of the menu has stayed; dishes such as frogs’ legs and finnan haddie haven’t. Recommended: colossal stone crabs, Nantucket Bay scallops, salmon baked with a macadamia-nut crust, house-made banana cream pie. More info: 516-621-0055, jollyfishermanrestaurant.com
 

The Jolly Fisherman & Steak House has been
Photo Credit: Bruce Gilbert

The Jolly Fisherman & Steak House in Roslyn.

The Jolly Fisherman & Steak House has been
Photo Credit: Bruce Gilbert

The Captain's Feast is one of the signature dishes at The Jolly Fisherman & Steak House in Roslyn.

Louie's Grill & Liquors (1905)

The clam shack of Louie's restaurant in Port
Photo Credit: Courtesy Louie's

Louie's Grill & Liquors (395 Main St., Port Washington): Louie’s started in 1905 as the “Kare Killer,” a floating eatery and saloon. It has undergone a few lives. The waterfront location and the view at sunset have been lures for decades, along with the traditional seafood and flavorful updates from new chef Tomo Kobayashi. Exit sauerbraten and cioppino. Recommended: gingery lobster Cantonese, New England-style lobster roll, New England clam chowder, bone-in rib-eye steak. More info: 516-883-4242, louiessince1905.com
 

Patrons sip wine and chat at one of
Photo Credit: Daniel Brennan

Patrons sip wine and chat at one of the high-top tables near the bar of Louie's Grill & Liquors in Port Washington.

An appetizer of herbed, steamed  Chilean sea
Photo Credit: Daniel Brennan

An appetizer of herbed, steamed Chilean sea bass, with baby bok choy and peas, is dressed  with black bean sauce at Louie's Grill & Liquors in Port Washington. 

Modern Snack Bar (1950)

The Modern Snack Bar on Route 25 in
Photo Credit: J. Michael Dombroski

Modern Snack Bar (628 Main Rd., Aquebogue): Modern Snack Bar came in during the Truman administration, at first selling hot dogs and hamburgers passed through a window. The Wittmeier family, which established and has owned it all these years, expanded the place into a warm restaurant that now seats 125 for dependably homey “comfort” food, either to eat in or take out. The mashed turnips are peerless. Recommended: seasonal Peconic Bay scallops, lobster salad, sauerbraten, loin of pork, roast duckling, pies. More info: 631-722-3655, modernsnackbar.com
 

Since 1950, the Modern Snack Bar has been
Photo Credit: Newsday/Audrey C. Tiernan

Modern Snack Bar in Aquebogue.

The lobster salad, right, and shrimp salad, left,
Photo Credit: Kirsten Luce

The lobster salad, right, and shrimp salad, left, can be enjoyed at the same time at Modern Snack Bar in Aquebogue.

Peter Luger (1960)

Waiters watch over tables at Peter Luger Steak
Photo Credit: Johnny Simon

Peter Luger (255 Northern Blvd., Great Neck): Here’s the suburban offspring of the Williamsburg classic, which opened in 1887 — 16 years before the Williamsburg Bridge. The Tudor-style Great Neck restaurant has been in business since 1960, with a similar if not identical menu. There is, of course, a prime reason to go to Peter Luger: one of the best steaks you’ll ever eat. Recommended: steak for two, three or four; “extra heavy cut” prime rib; broiled lobster; creamed spinach. More info: 516-487-8800, peterluger.com
 

FACING PAGE - TOP PHOTO - The porterhouse
Photo Credit: Johnny Simon

The porterhouse steak for two is a signature dish at Peter Luger in Great Neck, here, served with potato hash and creamed spinach.

Apple strudel comes with a flakey crust and
Photo Credit: Newsday/Johnny Simon

Apple strudel comes with a flakey crust and homemade schlag, sweet, thick, whipped cream, at Peter Luger in Great Neck.

The 1770 House (1930s)

The 1770 House in Southampton, circa 1963.
Photo Credit: East Hampton Historical Society

The 1770 House (143 Main St., East Hampton): A residence in 1663, this handsome place was converted to an inn in 1770 and evolved eventually into an ambitious, country restaurant. The modern restaurants are traceable to the 1930s and had dishes as different from each other as Chinese lemon chicken and cheese cannelloni. Wendy Perle Van Deusen, who owned the vintage spot from 1977 to 2002, balanced the traditions and the updating, as have newer owners, and current chef Michael Rozzi. Recommended: Hog’s Neck Bay oysters, Montauk fluke tartare, braised beef short rib, dry-rubbed Berkshire pork filet. More info: 631-324-1770, 1770house.com
 

Exterior of The 1770 House, at 143 Main
Photo Credit: Gordon M. Grant

The 1770 House in East Hampton.

Montauk fluke tartare, as served at The 1770
Photo Credit: Gordon M. Grant

Montauk fluke tartare, as served at The 1770 House in East Hampton.

Stella Ristorante (1960)

Interior of Stella Ristorante in 1960, Stella Ristorante,
Photo Credit: Yvonne Albinowski

Stella Ristorante (152 Jericho Tpke., Floral Park): Family-owned and operated, Stella came to Floral Park while John F. Kennedy was en route to the White House. It began in 1960 as a pizzeria and became a long-lived, traditional Italian-American restaurant. A portrait of the late “Mamma Stella” now welcomes diners, as she herself did for many years. Recommended: eggplant rollatini, lasagna, tagliatelle with prosciutto and tomato sauce, breaded and baked pork chop with broccoli rabe and roasted potatoes. More info: 516-775-2202, stellaristorante.com
 

Meat lasagna, Stella Ristorante, Floral Park, Mar. 26,
Photo Credit: Yvonne Albinowski

Meat lasagna, served at Stella Ristorante in Floral Park.

Latest reviews

Sorry to interrupt...

Your first 5 are free

Access to Newsday is free for Optimum customers.

Please enjoy 5 complimentary views to articles, photos, and videos during the next 30 days.

LOGIN SUBSCRIBE