Clear 49° Good Afternoon
Clear 49° Good Afternoon

Magic Fountain

Juliet Peters sits with her son Jack, 4,

Juliet Peters sits with her son Jack, 4, who enjoys a vanilla and chocolate ice cream cone at the Magic Fountain Ice Cream Shop in Mattituck. Photo Credit: James Carbone, 2009


9825 Main Rd. Mattituck, NY 11952



Magic Fountain is a family-owned store selling homemade ice cream. ... More »

Ali Choudry, owner of this popular North Fork sweet spot, has no shortage of imagination when creating unique flavors for his homemade ice cream, which he says he likes to make using foods from the local area. "Every season has its own different flavors," says Choudry, who was brewing green tea the other day for a new ice cream flavor. It has a vanilla base, he says, and "tastes like you're drinking a green tea."

Ice cream: Kulfi (popular Indian confection featuring rosewater, pistachio and cardamom), Chocolate Chili (starts with a chocolate-cinnamon taste, finishes with a hot and spicy kick), Coconut Avocado (coconut ice cream blended with real avocados equals sweet and creamy). 

Latest reviews

Sorry to interrupt...

Your first 5 are free

Access to Newsday is free for Optimum customers.

Please enjoy 5 complimentary views to articles, photos, and videos during the next 30 days.