TODAY'S PAPER
Scattered Clouds 40° Good Evening
Scattered Clouds 40° Good Evening
LifestyleRestaurants

Top tacos on LI: 18 must-visit restaurants

Tacos are the ultimate grab-and-go cuisine. But just because they're portable doesn't mean they shouldn't be made with care.

These LI restaurants create tacos with first-rate ingredients, from making the soft corn tortillas from scratch to slow-cooking meats until they're melt-in-your-mouth sumptuous.

5 de Mayo

Whether it's an order of carnitas, chorizo or
Photo Credit: Marisol Diaz

Whether it's an order of carnitas, chorizo or beef tongue, palm-sized tacos arrive in a flour tortilla double-layered, dressed with finely chopped cilantro and tomatoes, and served with salsas, rice and beans at 5 de Mayo in Westbury. They're straightforward and satisfying.

Wildfeast

Fish tacos are made with expertly fried hake
Photo Credit: Yvonne Albinowski

Fish tacos are made with expertly fried hake at Wildfeast in Long Beach.

JR El Rodeo

Fried tacos dorados with chicken and cheese are
Photo Credit: Marisol Diaz

Fried tacos dorados with chicken and cheese are served at JR El Rodeo in East Moriches.

Nelly's Taqueria

For taco buffs, fresh handmade tortillas are the
Photo Credit: Yvonne Albinowski

For taco buffs, fresh handmade tortillas are the Holy Grail. Hicksville now has a worthy pilgrimage site. Every taco at Nelly's Taqueria is made with corn tortillas that chef Nelly Palacios makes by hand with fresh masa (cornmeal dough). Their flavor is earthier, their texture more delicate than store-bought. Fillings include pork, chicken, steak and fish (grilled, not fried).

Lucharitos Taqueria and Tequila Bar

Tacos at Lucharitos Taqueria and Tequila Bar in
Photo Credit: Randee Daddona

Tacos at Lucharitos Taqueria and Tequila Bar in Greenport are best ordered traditional style, in soft corn tortillas topped with salsa verde, pickled radish, chopped onion and cilantro.

One Block East

Chopped brisket tacos on soft corn tortillas with
Photo Credit: Aaron Zebrook

Chopped brisket tacos on soft corn tortillas with a bright pico de gallo are nothing short of sensational at One Block East in Wantagh.

Salamander General Store

Salamander General Store in Greenport is famous for
Photo Credit: Newsday / Erica Marcus

Salamander General Store in Greenport is famous for its fried chicken, but the fish tacos are every bit as good. The fish, crisp and light, are perfectly complemented by fresh green salsa and guacamole.

Oaxaca Mexican Food Treasure

Authenticity and depth of flavor define the soft
Photo Credit: Newsday / Joan Reminick

Authenticity and depth of flavor define the soft corn tacos at Oaxaca Mexican Food Treasure in Huntington. Favorites include chorizo tacos, tacos al pastor (made with roasted spice-coated pork) and carnitas tacos with citrus-marinated pork.

Pinatas Mexican Grill

Among the winning soft corn tacos at Pinatas
Photo Credit: Timothy Fadek

Among the winning soft corn tacos at Pinatas Mexican Grill in Bethpage are the spicy chorizo, the succulent tongue and the authentic fish tacos. Request sauce on the side.

Pico Tequila Grill

Admirably, corn tortillas are house-made at Pico Tequila
Photo Credit: Heather Walsh

Admirably, corn tortillas are house-made at Pico Tequila Grill in Bay Shore, but you have to request them. A carne asada "street" taco (pictured) with grilled beef, salsa verde, onion and cheese is a treat. So, too, is a taco of pork, pico de gallo and avocado sauce.

Taqueria Cielito Lindo

The menu is impressive at Riverhead's Taqueria Cielito
Photo Credit: Gordon M. Grant

The menu is impressive at Riverhead's Taqueria Cielito Lindo, with tacos that feature handmade soft corn tortillas, savory pozole rojo and a unique spin on the Cubana torta. This taco trio (from left): campechanos (in the style of the province of Campeche, made with several different kinds of meat), de lengua (tongue), and al pastor (shepherd style, with spit-roasted pork and grilled pineapple).

Little Mexico

At genuine Mexican eatery Little Mexico in Westbury,
Photo Credit: Newsday / Erica Marcus

At genuine Mexican eatery Little Mexico in Westbury, you can get all manner of soft corn tacos, including tacos de lengua, piled with succulent cubes of beef tongue, pork (pastor) and chorizo (sausage), plus all the fixings.

El Paso Taco Grill

Spanish is the predominant language at this authentic
Photo Credit: Newsday / Joan Reminick

Spanish is the predominant language at this authentic taqueria that draws a taco-savvy clientele. At El Paso Taco Grill in Farmingdale, the soft corn tacos are filled generously. The taco al pastor, stuffed with marinated roasted pork, is a treat. Better still is the taco de lengua (tongue taco, pictured) crammed with juicy pieces of well-marinated grilled beef tongue.

Chichimecas

Bi-level Farmingdale Mexican restaurant Chichimecas serves authentic soft
Photo Credit: Johnny Simon

Bi-level Farmingdale Mexican restaurant Chichimecas serves authentic soft corn tacos al pastor, with roasted spice-coated pork, chopped onion and cilantro, chicken (pictured) and other choices, too.

Taqueria Mexico

Taqueria Mexico in Riverhead makes spare, elegant tacos
Photo Credit: Gordon M. Grant

Taqueria Mexico in Riverhead makes spare, elegant tacos with homemade tortillas. Try the toothsome tongue, the subtly fiery tacos de longaniza, or Mexican spicy sausage, and lush, braised pork carnitas (pictured), all topped with cilantro and chopped onion.

El Ranchito Mexican Grill

Fine soft corn tacos are the rule at
Photo Credit: Newsday / Rebecca Cooney

Fine soft corn tacos are the rule at El Ranchito Mexican Grill in East Northport. There's juicy beef tongue, smoky crisp carnitas (pork) and a fish taco (pictured) made with lightly breaded red snapper topped with cabbage and pico de gallo.

Señor Nacho

Street tacos at Señor Nacho in Great Neck
Photo Credit: Jin Lee

Street tacos at Señor Nacho in Great Neck mean soft corn tortillas piled with your choice of filling, showered with cilantro and served with lime and sliced radishes. Best is the succulent tongue and spicy pork al pastor, featuring rotisserie-roasted marinated meat.

Mi Ranchito Bar & Grill

Authenticity informs the tacos Jalisco at Mi Ranchito
Photo Credit: Yvonne Albinowski

Authenticity informs the tacos Jalisco at Mi Ranchito in Port Washington: Soft corn tortillas are crowned with juicy, smoky cubes of grilled skirt steak showered with cilantro and chopped onion, plated with a spirited salsa verde.

Latest reviews

Sorry to interrupt...

Your first 5 are free

Access to Newsday is free for Optimum customers.

Please enjoy 5 complimentary views to articles, photos, and videos during the next 30 days.

LOGIN SUBSCRIBE