Broken Clouds 43° Good Morning
Broken Clouds 43° Good Morning

South Edison


The "bicycle room" at South Edison restaurant in Montauk. Photo Credit: Handout


17 S. Edison St. Montauk, NY 11954



$$$ (Expensive)


In its third season, South Edison keeps its carefully cultivated, surf-town cool. This sharp spot, ... More »

In the time it takes to towel off and freshen up, you'll go from the beach to the dining room at South Edison.

This new addition to downtown eating is situated midway between Montauk Highway and the ocean, about two blocks each way. Come for the raw bar in late afternoon or for a creative combo of New American and surf-and-turf from 5:30 p.m.

It's the model of a summer eatery in a beachy town. The restaurant is awash in sunny and aquatic hues. South Edison sports a busy bar, with brews on tap, and a menu of uncomplicated but stylish dishes in the appropriately named, bright and light Bike Room and Surf Room.

Chef Todd Mitgang heads very east after cooking at Cascabel Taqueria and Kittichai in Manhattan.

You'll walk slightly north from the sands for plates of littlenecks and cherrystones, assorted oysters and crabs, plus the obligatory shrimp and lobster cocktails. Consider this a leisurely, pre-dinner stop.

Mitgang updates and juices up a buttery lobster roll with black-garlic mayo. Day-boat fluke sashimi vies with a spicy tuna BLT chalupa completed with house-smoked bacon and warm tortillas. Of course, there's linguine with clam sauce, here with littlenecks and fresh tomato, clam broth and lemon. The carnivorous can enjoy a sliced strip steak, cherry-cola braised pork belly and jerk-roasted Crescent Farm duck breast.

If there's room: the salted-caramel, fudge-brownie ice cream sandwich, a contemporary riff on a summer classic.


Latest reviews

Sorry to interrupt...

Your first 5 are free

Access to Newsday is free for Optimum customers.

Please enjoy 5 complimentary views to articles, photos, and videos during the next 30 days.