44° Good Morning
44° Good Morning

The Arden review

Tuna two ways is a well-fashioned duo of

Tuna two ways is a well-fashioned duo of sashimi and tartare at The Arden in Port Jefferson. Photo Credit: Daniel Brennan

The Arden is situated above Starbucks. Maybe caffeine does drift upward.

You've attended sudden-death sporting events quieter than a night here. But that amped-up sound must be part of the new establishment's appeal. Or it could be that the spirits of the departed Original Elk Hotel are very restless.

Enter at street level, passing a velvet rope line, and climb a seasonally decorated stairway to reach the "ultra lounge" for "vibe dining." The bar acts as focal point and room divider. Tables line the rim of what will morph into a dance floor, as well as the area on the other side of beverage central.

And The Arden's kitchen specializes in entertainment, plus fare that's complemented by a drink or five, from small plates to large.

Duck tacos are respectable, with an Asian-style slaw. Little burritos packed with cod, lettuce, tomato, rice and ancho-chile flavored aioli, are husky and all right with a beer. The lobster bruschetta, however, defines travesty. It's served with "wanton chips," a typo that overstates the lustiness.

You're better off with the tender, root-beer braised short ribs; and the trio of sliders, which takes in a Waygu beef burger, Buffalo-style chicken and Taylor ham and cheese. The Buffalo-style chicken wings are meaty, though sauced mildly even when ordered spicy. The "atomic shrimp," neither molecular nor nuclear, is lifted by Gorgonzola cream.

Flatbreads arrive on a board that resembles an unwieldy cricket bat, challenging the staff and the size of your table. But they're fine. The fig-and-goat cheese number with caramelized onions stands out. From the sushi selection comes a well-fashioned duo of tuna sashimi and tuna tartare.

The largest of large plates: the bone-in, 40-ounce Tomahawk rib-eye steak -- a chewy, charbroiled, $49 disappointment. Fish-and-chips is a modest improvement. Grilled BBQ swordfish arrives sliced perilously thin and overcooked.

Two regular desserts, cheesecake and rice pudding, are skippable. But at that street-level Starbucks, you may find an old-fashioned glazed doughnut or an iced lemon cheesecake to accompany your cinnamon dolce latte or espresso con panna.


We're revamping our Comments section. Learn more and share your input.

Latest reviews