76° Good Evening
76° Good Evening

This week’s restaurant reviews

18 Bay Restaurant is located on Shelter Island

18 Bay Restaurant is located on Shelter Island and features local fish and produce. (July 9, 2011)

Peter Gianotti bestows three stars on 18 Bay in Shelter Island. “Elizabeth Ronzetti and Adam Kopels, the owners and chefs, closed their cozy Bayville eatery in summer 2010. They relocated the restaurant to Shelter Island last summer and now run the ideal country eatery.”

Joan Reminick visits Chichimecas in Farmingdale, the latest Mexican venture from Alex and Maria González (who also own Oaxaca and Quetzalcoatl in Huntington). The location, just north of the LIRR tracks, has been the downfall of a string of restaurants, but with its accomplished and authentic Mexican offerings, Chichimecas “may prove to be the keeper.”

On the porch at 18 Bay, Shelter Island

Latest reviews