Good Evening
Good Evening

Umberto's of New Hyde Park

Vincenzo Corteo, nephew of owner Umberto Corteo, puts

Vincenzo Corteo, nephew of owner Umberto Corteo, puts the finishing touches on one of their famous "Godfather Heros." Credit: Peter Dilauro

This is "the original Umberto's," and the best of all the establishments that now carry the popular name. Come here for very good pizzas and hearty southern Italian food. The restaurant itself is casual despite the refurbishing that might make it seem more. You'll do well with a hot antipasto, stuffed mushrooms, mozzarella in any guise, The spaghetti alla puttanesca and the rigatoni al filetto di pomodoro are dependable choices. Likewise, manicotti, stuffed shells, eggplant rollatine and eggplant Parmigiana. From the pizza selections, try the basic Neapolitan, the Grandma Sicilian and the thicker more traditional Sicilian pies. Fine brick-oven Margherita pizza, and pizza capped with fresh roasted peppers and sausage; or with ham, onion, garlic, olives and fresh tomato. The cheese calzones also are recommended. And a plate of broccoli rabe with sausage will do, too.

Reader Reviews

"I will travel 30 minutes just to get it when there are plenty of pizza joints within walking distance from my house. NOTHING compares!!" says Maureen of Long Beach.

"You couldn't find a better tasting pizza...even if you went to Italy! Umberto himself actually does routine randomized taste tests of his product to ensure his pizza's consistency and quality! How can you beat that?" says Mark of Huntington.

"I took some Rhode Island buddies to Umberto's. After having one bite into the famous Sicilian, they all dropped the pizza and said, 'Now we know why you complain about pizza in New England,'' says Brain of Warwick, RI.

"It's the perfect blend of spice with a rich and robust sauce. Several cheeses used are of the highest quality. On a scale of 1-10, I'll rate it 1,000!!! One of my nephews comes from New Jersey to purchase and freeze their pizzas," says Gigi of Port Washington.

"Classic sauce and crust. Sicilian to die for and a regular that stands up with the rest. Even coming back to the NYC area 22 years after I moved to still rates!" says Paul of Sydney, Australia.

"I've had pizza in some of the best 'so-called' pizzerias in the NY metro area. Nothing comes close to an Umberto's Sicilian pie. NOTHING!" says Chris of New Hyde Park. 

Latest reviews