Good Morning
Good Morning
Long IslandCrime

James Burke, former Suffolk police chief of department, indicted, sources say

Sources say former Suffolk chief of detectives James

Sources say former Suffolk chief of detectives James Burke was indicted by a grand jury on Tuesday. Credit: Ed Betz

A federal grand jury indicted James Burke, the former Suffolk County Police chief of department, Tuesday, several sources said.

The grand jury had been investigating allegations that Burke and other police officers beat and then covered up the assault on a Smithtown man who stole a duffel bag from the chief’s department SUV.

Burke, of St. James, the highest-ranking uniformed officer on the force until he resigned in October, was scheduled to be arraigned Wednesday at the federal court in Central Islip, the sources said.

Top Justice Department officials in the area are scheduled to hold a news conference on the case Wednesday.

Burke’s attorney, Joseph Conway, of Mineola, said Tuesday night that he has not been contacted about surrendering his client. The Eastern District could not be reached for comment.

The exact charges Burke faces could not be determined immediately, but the grand jury was known to be questioning witnesses about the possibility that violations of civil rights occurred, as well as a subsequent cover-up of the attack, which would amount to obstruction of justice.

More than a dozen Suffolk police officers in 2012 were either at the Smithtown precinct or at the home of Christopher Loeb at the time the Smithtown man was detained. Loeb has said he was assaulted initially at his home by officers and subsequently at the precinct, where he was beaten by Burke and other officers.

None of those officers are believed to have been charged so far in the case, and several are believed to have been cooperating with federal investigators.

The grand jury at the federal courthouse in Central Islip started in late spring to look into the case. The new grand jury had revived an investigation that had remained dormant since the beginning of 2014.

Both grand jury investigations were triggered by the 2012 theft of Burke’s duffel bag. Newsday had reported the existence of the new grand jury probe last month.

Since those same questions were asked during the initial investigation without any charges being brought, it is believed that federal investigators have acquired new evidence, the sources said.

That evidence might include wiretapped information, several of the law enforcement officers involved changing their accounts of what occurred or both, the sources said.

Several of the sources have said that some officers are now cooperating with investigators.

At least three officers have been identified by sources as cooperating with the grand jury. Their attorneys have declined to comment.

Federal investigators have focused their questioning of the Suffolk police almost solely on two different subjects: what happened at Loeb’s house and the precinct, and what was in Burke’s duffel bag, the sources said.

The duffel bag question centered on if it contained pornography, the sources said.

Suffolk police have said the duffel contained a department gun belt, ammunition, handcuffs, a whistle and a box of cigars.

Amy Marion, an attorney for Loeb, 29, has said that her client claims the duffel contained sex toys and DVDs of “nasty porn.” Marion, of Garden City, said Burke’s reason for going to the scene was to recover the duffel and that was the motivation for his being enraged enough to later beat her client in the precinct.

Loeb pleaded guilty to the 2012 theft of the duffel bag from a department SUV parked in front of then-Chief Burke’s St. James home.

Loeb also has filed a federal lawsuit against the county, Burke and other police officers, accusing them of violating his civil rights.


1986. James Burke is hired by Suffolk County Police Department.

1991. Promoted to sergeant.

2000. Becomes a lieutenant.

2002. Assigned to district attorney’s office to lead detectives squad.

2004. Named inspector by District Attorney Thomas Spota.

2012. Becomes chief of department.

Dec. 14, 2012. Christopher Loeb is arrested at his Smithtown home on charges related to allegations he stole a police gun belt and ammunition from a vehicle used by Burke. Loeb is held on $500,000 bail.

Dec. 28. Spota indicts Loeb, then 26, on 30 counts related to breaking into more than a dozen cars in St. James on Dec. 14.

Feb. 15, 2013. Spota’s office requests a special prosecutor “to avoid any resulting appearance of impropriety. “ Queens prosecutor Peter Crusco is assigned.

June 15. Sources reveal Burke arrived at Loeb’s home moments after his arrest to personally retrieve his bag.

June 19. Loeb’s mother, Jane, says her son wrote her a letter alleging he was “beat up” in his home during his arrest and then “even worse at the precinct,” and he says it was Burke who punched him. Law enforcement sources also reveal Burke went to the Fourth Precinct, where Loeb was being processed, and had the detectives’ squad room cleared of everyone except for Loeb and himself. Burke vehemently denies any wrongdoing.

June 25. The FBI launches an investigation into Burke’s actions during Loeb’s arrest to see if he violated Loeb’s civil rights. It serves subpoenas on nearly a dozen Suffolk police officers, detectives and headquarters personnel to appear before a federal grand jury.

July 21. Newsday reports that at least 10 probation and police officers went to the home to conduct the search, according to law enforcement sources and Loeb’s family. Sources say joint operations involving the police and probation departments on a low-level offender such as Loeb are rare.

July 31. Det. Thomas Cottingham, the lead investigator in the case against Loeb, retires after 21 years on the force.

Oct. 20. Newsday reports that a 1995 internal affairs probe admonished Burke for twice losing his police-issued service weapon and carrying on a sexual relationship with “a felon known to be actively engaged in criminal conduct including the possession and sale of illegal drugs, prostitution and larceny. “

Jan. 15, 2014. Queens Special Prosecutor Peter Crusco announces in a filing of a motion that the federal civil rights probe against Burke has been dropped. Federal authorities decline to say whether the investigation was closed.

Jan. 24. Loeb pleads guilty to third-degree criminal possession of a weapon.

April 18. Loeb is sentenced to 3 years in prison. He insists his constitutional rights were violated because Burke beat him while in custody - a charge Burke denies.

Feb. 6, 2015. Loeb files a federal lawsuit against Burke and Suffolk County, claiming his civil rights were violated during his arrest. Loeb alleges Burke “personally took part in and personally orchestrated” the alleged beating. He seeks compensation for damages in excess of $150,000.

May 1. After a hearing before a U.S. magistrate judge, Loeb’s attorney Amy Marion said Burke had pornography and “disturbing items” in his duffel bag that may have prompted him to act the way he did.

Oct. 27, 2015. Burke resigned his chief of department post as federal officials reactivated their probe into police conduct in the theft of the chief’s duffel bag.

Latest Long Island News