Good Evening
Good Evening
Long IslandNassau

DA: Son admits missing-dad insurance plot

Jonathan Roth is escorted out of Nassau police

Jonathan Roth is escorted out of Nassau police headquarters in Mineola. (Aug. 7, 2012) Credit: Howard Schnapp

A Massapequa man has admitted knowing his father was alive and well -- even as he filed a missing-person report and tried to cash in on a life insurance policy, prosecutors said in a criminal complaint filed Tuesday.

Jonathan Roth, 22, knew that his father -- feared drowned in the ocean on July 28 -- "was not missing because he observed him leave Jones Beach after informing the defendant that he was going to flee secretly to Florida," the complaint states.

Prosecutors also say Roth tried to collect on his father's MetLife insurance policy, valued at more than $50,000.

Judge Sondra K. Pardes of First District Court in Hempstead, remanded Roth on $5,000 cash bail or $10,000 bond.

Roth pleaded not guilty Tuesday to second-degree insurance fraud and fourth-degree conspiracy, both felonies; and to falsely reporting an incident and making a false written declaration, both misdemeanors.

In court papers, prosecutors said Roth admitted to the scheme Monday.

On July 28, he told State Park Police that he saw his father, Raymond, 47, walk into the ocean until he was chest deep, and had not seen him since, the complaint stated.

The son stood by as authorities conducted a massive search, using a helicopter, 40 lifeguards, five fire department dive teams, marine patrols and the U.S. Coast Guard.

"The defendant at all times was fully aware that his father never walked into the water and had, in fact, driven off in his personal vehicle," the criminal complaint said.

Authorities said Tuesday they now know where Raymond Roth is, but would not reveal his location. They said they are continuing to investigate his role in the scheme.

Lenard Leeds, the Carle Place attorney representing Raymond Roth's wife, Evana, 45, of Massapequa, said he learned last week that Raymond Roth, who recently lost his job, tripled the value of his life insurance policy in January.

Leeds said his client, rocked by the revelations, has filed for divorce and "is trying to put her life back together."

Jonathan Roth told Newsday on Saturday that he thought his father had drowned. "I had no idea about this plan, this plot, whatever you want to call it," he said.

His girlfriend, Kristi Mayleas, 22, said she and Roth went to the Nassau district attorney's office in Mineola on Monday to pick up the cellphone he had turned over to investigators. He was arrested when he got there, much to his shock, she said.

Raymond Roth was presumed drowned for days until his brother called police last Wednesday to say Roth was in Orlando, Fla., where he has a time share. The same day, an officer in Santee, S.C., gave Roth a speeding ticket.

About two weeks before he disappeared, Raymond Roth indicated to a co-worker that he had his gun with him and was going to harm his employer, who had demoted him, Nassau police said.

After learning of the incident, police contacted Roth and asked him to turn in his gun and pistol permit, said Sgt. Sal Mistretta, commanding officer of the department's Pistol License section. Mistretta said the permit was suspended because Roth is being investigated on a harassment charge in the city, and also because he allegedly took his pistol into New York City, where he's not allowed to possess a gun.

With Alison Barnwell,

Kery Murakami

and Matthew Chayes

Nassau top stories