Gov. Andrew M. Cuomo’s direct intervention led PSEG Long Island to acquiesce to LIPA’s demands in talks in late June on a contract that would keep the New Jersey company as grid manager, a top LIPA official testified Monday.
The comments at a state Assembly energy committee hearing in Brookhaven came as a bipartisan group of state and local lawmakers expressed interest in shifting the Long Island Power Authority back on course toward becoming a fully public utility.
LIPA has said the public option would save ratepayers more than $80 million a year.
During the hearing, Assemb. Steve Englebright (D-Setauket), a public-power supporter, asked LIPA chief executive Tom Falcone, "Were you told what to do by the governor?" in pursuit of a contract with PSEG.
Falcone testified that Cuomo recently had read an account in Newsday about a LIPA board meeting in which a top PSEG official told LIPA the company would continue to fight to keep its $80 million a year contract, despite LIPA’s continued issues with PSEG’s performance.
Falcone recalled, "The governor read it and he said, ‘I’ve had enough,’ and he made a phone call [to PSEG] and … he said, ‘I want a decision. You’re either in or you’re out, and if you’re not, in a few days, you’re out. That’s it.’"
Falcone said PSEG "decided they wanted to be in. And it went from a negotiation that for six months went nowhere to one where suddenly they gave us everything we wanted."
PSEG agreed to a contract terms that essentially put half its $80 million a year fee at risk of loss if it failed to meet new performance metrics.
The agreement also would settle LIPA’s breach of contract suit against PSEG with $30 million in givebacks, commit PSEG to a beefed up company management staff and new levels of accountability, and gives LIPA the ability to terminate the contract in 2025.
Cuomo spokeswoman Haley Viccaro acknowledged the governor had "told LIPA and PSEG LI to either reach an agreement or sever ties."
Nevertheless, Viccaro said the tentative contract terms, "will improve operations, accountability, transparency and, most importantly, customer service."
She continued: "Nothing in this stronger renegotiated agreement precludes further exploration and pursuit of a municipal model, which would need to be authorized by legislation."
A PSEG spokeswoman declined to address Falcone’s comments directly, but pointed to testimony at the hearing by Chris Hahn, PSEG’s director of external affairs.
Hahn said LIPA leadership "should be commended" for moving ahead with PSEG.
"I believe its leadership recognized that dismantling the LIPA-PSEG relationship following our telecommunications issues during [Tropical Storm] Isaias would mean that hard lessons learned would have to be relearned by someone else during the next storm," Hahn testified.
At the hearing Tuesday, lawmakers condemned the public-private model that keeps PSEG Long Island running the system, and criticized PSEG for its performance failures during Isaiah and other storms.
Assemb. Fred Thiele (I-Sag Harbor) said the utility was in the same spot it was after enactment of the LIPA Reform Act of 2013, Cuomo’s legislation that gave PSEG an expanded role in running the LIPA system.
The law merely served to, "consolidate control over LIPA in the governor’s office," Thiele said. "We should be looking at other options, we should be looking at public power."
Falcone defended the new contract with PSEG. But he noted it still hasn’t been finalized and voted on by the LIPA board, and it won’t be in full effect until January.
Falcone agreed to make the agreement available publicly 30 days before the board vote, and stressed the contract would give the authority numerous options for terminating the PSEG contract.
"If the [state] legislature passes a bill that says we should municipalize management we have a right to terminate," Falcone said, noting LIPA would "have to pay a termination fee in that case."
Other local and state lawmakers including Brookhaven Town Supervisor Edward Romaine, a Republican, Suffolk County Legis. Bridget Fleming (D-Noyac) and Assembly members support the public power option.
Assemb. Doug Smith (R-Holbrook), took it a step further, calling for LIPA to be "abolished as it currently exists," and for PSEG to be "unplugged," in favor of public power.
Hahn said there would be future storms and some customers would lose power but said PSEG had "acquired the street knowledge to make it an even more effective partner in protecting Long Island’s energy grid."