TODAY'S PAPER
40° Good Evening
40° Good Evening
Long Island

Officials criticize proposed LI Sound crossing at Oyster Bay

Environmentalists and commercial fisherman also were critical of a state proposal for a tunnel crossing at Oyster Bay. A recent study says the other viable tunnel crossing is in Kings Park.

On Thursday, March 1, 2018, Sen. Carl Marcellino, along with local officials, community activists and environmental groups, held a rally in Oyster Bay in opposition of a tunnel or bridge/tunnel combination from Syosset to Rye. (Credit: Howard Schnapp)

The Long Island Sound tunnel being promoted by Gov. Andrew M. Cuomo would “destroy the environment,” local officials said Thursday.

About a dozen elected officials, along with environmentalists and commercial fishermen, assailed the plan at a news conference in Oyster Bay in language that at times bordered on the apocalyptic.

“It would destroy the environment. It would destroy Long Island, and we need to stop it now,” Oyster Bay Town Councilwoman Michele Johnson said.

State Department of Transportation spokesman Joseph Morrissey said in an email that the agency “continues to explore opportunities to reduce congestion and enhance the competitiveness of Long Island. This is the beginning of a longer conversation on how to best proceed.”

DOT is committed to “extensive outreach” with affected communities, local officials and stakeholders, he added.

The governor proposed studying the feasibility of a new link between Long Island and the mainland in 2016, resurrecting a plan periodically circulated among regional planners, government officials and property developers since at least 1938, when a U.S. Senate committee suggested an 18-mile bridge from Orient Point across Plum, Gull and Fishers islands and on to either Groton, Connecticut, or Watch Hill, Rhode Island.

The most recent incarnations, outlined in an 87-page study the state released in January, included links to Westchester or Connecticut from Oyster Bay Town in Nassau County, or to Connecticut from Kings Park in Suffolk County.

The subsequent announcement from Cuomo’s office did not mention a potential link to Connecticut. A DOT spokesman said in January that a Westchester link appeared to be most feasible, though he cautioned that “we are still in the early stages” of planning.

A Sound tunnel would cost $31.5 billion to $55.4 billion, depending on location and whether there are one or two tubes, the study found.

The study’s authors estimated between 74,300 and 86,400 vehicles would use a tunnel to Westchester per day. Together, drivers would pay more than $500 million in tolls per year, if the fee were $20 to $25 per trip.

State funding for the project is not certain. State Sen. Carl Marcellino (R-Syosset) said Thursday the project would be a “$55 billion boondoggle.” In addition to Marcellino, State Senate Majority Leader John J. Flanagan (R-East Northport), the state’s top Republican, has said he opposes it.

Few Long Island leaders appear ready to welcome a tunnel or bridge into their own communities, though not all have rejected the idea of a Long Island link. Joseph Saladino, Oyster Bay Town supervisor, said in early January that the only viable option for a Sound crossing was in Kings Park. Assemb. Michael Fitzpatrick (R-St. James) returned the favor a few days later, telling a Newsday reporter that “I would love to see a bridge or tunnel on the Seaford-Oyster Bay Expressway, where it belongs.”

Along with elected officials, Thursday’s news conference at the Theodore Roosevelt Memorial Park boat launching ramps in Oyster Bay attracted a small crowd of environmentalists, baymen and at least one professional comedian.

Jackie Martling, a former writer for “The Howard Stern Show” who lives in Bayville, pledged to fight what he said was “nothing short of total destruction” of the community.

Latest Long Island News