Good Morning
Good Morning
Long IslandTransportation

Long Island business groups urge Garden City not to slow down Third Track project

Acting MTA chairman and chief executive officer Janno

Acting MTA chairman and chief executive officer Janno Lieber last week called Garden City's refusal to grant the permits a "NIMBY [not in my backyard] action." Credit: Howard Simmons

Several Long Island business groups are urging the Village of Garden City to stop slowing progress on the Long Island Rail Road’s Third Track project, noting that further delays will only "increase the cost to all parties."

In a letter obtained by Newsday that was sent to Garden City officials on Monday, the heads of the Association for a Better Long Island, Long Island Association and Long Island Builders Institute said they would "strongly counsel" the village to approve permits applied for by the railroad months ago to advance its LIRR Expansion project.

The $2.6 billion project aims to construct a 10-mile-long third track between Floral Park and Hicksville, including through Garden City. Project officials have said it will reduce LIRR delays and facilitate "reverse commuting" to and from jobs on Long Island.

"As a result, it will spur transit-oriented economic and community development, essential if Long Island is to be competitive in attracting new businesses and young people who live in New York City," the letter’s authors said. "The project will add billions in personal income, sales & property tax revenue, and gross regional product."

Village officials did not respond to requests for comment.

After boasting of keeping the Third Track on budget and on schedule since it was proposed in 2016, officials with the Metropolitan Transportation Authority — the LIRR’s parent agency — recently said the project is at risk of missing its December 2022 completion date.

The MTA has blamed the village, which has not granted permits needed to replace a rail bridge on Denton Avenue to make it wide enough to accommodate an extra track. The MTA has asked the state Supreme Court to compel the village, which previously approved the project’s design, to issue the permits.

Village officials have not publicly commented about the dispute, because of the pending litigation. The dispute comes following a separate lawsuit filed by the village against the railroad, complaining about the placement of several utility poles near Merillon Avenue Station. The state Supreme Court threw out that suit in July.

Speaking for the first time on the matter, acting MTA chairman and chief executive officer Janno Lieber last week called the village’s refusal to grant the permits a "NIMBY [not in my backyard] action."

"It’s clearly retaliation for the fact that they lost the lawsuit — that we got a one-sided decision … They lost, and now they won’t give us the permits to do work that is pretty routine," Lieber said. "There are a lot of people in Garden City who are wondering why their own community is stopping this project, which so clearly benefits Garden City, as well as the rest of Long Island."

Lieber acknowledged the delayed bridge work, which was supposed to begin in March, has set back the project, but added that the Third Track team will "turn themselves into pretzels to make sure we make schedule and budget."

MTA officials have said recouping the lost time could require extending construction work into nights, weekends and the winter months, and running up costs in overtime and other expenses.

In the letter, the business leaders added that "to delay further means the courts would ultimately dictate when construction begins and unnecessarily increase the cost to all parties."

"It is unfathomable that a routine construction permit could delay one of Long Island's most transformative infrastructure projects of our generation," Kyle Strober, executive director of the Assocation for a Better Long Island, said in a statement Monday.

Mitchell Pally, chief executive officer of the Long Island Builders Institute, in an interview, called the impasse with the village "absolutely ridiculous."

"We cannot let one village stand in the way of progress on Long Island," Pally said.

Matthew Cohen, president of the Long Island Association, said he’d like to see the dispute resolved outside of the courts, with village officials coming to appreciate the benefits of the Third Track, including to its own residents.

"My hope is that reason will prevail," Cohen said.

Latest Long Island News