47° Good Morning
47° Good Morning
NewsNew York

Column: Yanks shouldn't take the bait

Robinson Cano

Robinson Cano Credit: Robinson Cano #24 of the New York Yankees. (Jim McIsaac)

Let me get this straight: Even with Robinson Cano posting his usual MVP-caliber numbers, the Yankees failed to reach the postseason. And he wants the largest contract in baseball history? Ca-no thank you.

Time and again, elite ballplayers are proving it’s a bad idea to give lucrative, super-long-term contracts to players over the age of 30. Alex Rodriguez in 2008 and Albert Pujols in 2011 immediately come to mind. Each received a 10-year deal worth at least $240 million.

But Cano is far from on par with what those two were at the time they received their big paydays. At 33, A-Rod was a year removed from his third MVP award, and Pujols was Cano’s age and coming off a second World Series title. Oh, and he was a three-time MVP as well.

Cano hasn’t done enough to warrant such a reward. He’s a five-time All-Star with a World Series ring, but that’s about it. No disrespect to the baseball’s top second baseman, but nothing about those credentials — or this year’s results — makes Cano worth the kind of cash or years he’s reportedly seeking.

It’s fair to say the Yankees’ rough 2013 would have been a disaster had Cano not been around, so it’s a scary proposition to imagine him walking away this offseason. But if it means paying $31 million per year until he’s 40, it would be better to let Cano walk.

Scott Fontana can be reached at


We're revamping our Comments section. Learn more and share your input.

More news