50° Good Morning
50° Good Morning
NewsNew York

Pence’s skidding plane had inoperable speed reducer, NTSB says

Republican vice-presidential nominee Mike Pence was not hurt

Republican vice-presidential nominee Mike Pence was not hurt after his campaign plane skidded off a rain-slicked runway while landing at LaGuardia Airport on Thursday night, Oct. 27, 2016. He is pictured with first responders at the scene. Photo Credit: TV Network Pool via AP

This story was reported by Laura Blasey, Matthew Chayes, Chau Lam, Ellen Yan and Gary Dymski.

A device that automatically helps planes reduce speed on landing was not functioning on the campaign plane carrying Republican vice-presidential nominee Mike Pence that ran off the end of a runway Thursday night at LaGuardia Airport, a federal safety official said Friday.

The spoilers on the planes’ wings that create drag normally deploy automatically about one second after landing, but had to be deployed manually by the pilot of the Pence plane about four seconds after touch down, the official said.

The automatic feature on the device, called a speed brake actuator, had been inoperable for two days, said Robert Sumwalt, a member of the National Transportation Safety Board. It was not known whether the pilot of the plane was aware of the problem, and Sumwalt said the crew would be interviewed Saturday.

Sumwalt, during a news conference at the Queens airport, did not provide any more information on that point. He said the board is not yet giving a cause of the accident.

Investigators have not pinpointed the spot on the runway where the plane touched down, but the plane’s approach speed was 130 knots (about 150 mph) at the time, which Sumwalt said “does not appear to be out of the ordinary to me.” He said the speed at touch down was 122 knots.

The Boeing 737-700 was on lease from Eastern Airlines, a charter air service that could not be reached for comment.

Sumwalt said the flight recorder was recovered from the plane and sent to the NTSB lab in Washington, D.C., for examination.

The plane landed on a rain-slicked runway about 7:42 p.m. Thursday was brought to a halt about 200 feet past the end of the runway after entering a bed of crushable material that slows the wheels of a plane.

Pence appeared on several morning television news shows Friday and called the landing “10 seconds of uncertainty.”

“When we landed, it was obvious I think to everybody on the plane that the pilots were hitting the brakes very hard,” Pence, the governor of Indiana, said on one show.

He and his campaign staff left aboard another leased plane later Friday for appearances in Pennsylvania and North Carolina.

The plane, which had taken off hours earlier Thursday from an airport in Fort Dodge, Iowa, after a Pence rally there, carried 37 passengers and 11 crew members, Port Authority officials said.

The website carried audio of an air traffic controller watching the landing and saying: “Eastern stop. Stop Eastern,” a reference to the Pence plane’s designation as Eastern Flight 3452.

The controller then directed other planes waiting to land to “go around,” meaning they should not land. “The airport is closed,” the controller said.

Passengers said as the aircraft flew over the city in preparation to land, it knifed through hard rain, strong winds and thick fog. Turbulence jostled the twin-engine jet.

When the plane touched down on the 7,000-foot runway, it vibrated and then jerked violently while sliding, a passenger said.

“You could feel the plane skidding,” CNN producer Elizabeth Landers, who was seated in the back of the plane, said in an interview on the network. The plane “felt like it fishtailed.”


March 5, 2015. A Delta Air Lines Boeing MD-88 with 127 passengers and five crew aboard veers off a snowy Runway 13, hits a fence and stops with its left wing leaking fuel onto a berm overlooking Flushing Bay. Federal investigators blamed pilot error; 29 people had minor injuries.

July 22, 2013. Nose gear on a Southwest Airlines jet landing at airport collapses, sending the aircraft skidding down the runway and injuring 10 of the 143 passengers.

Oct. 19, 1996. Delta Air Lines jetliner skids off runway while landing in a nor’easter. The plane stops just short of Flushing Bay, with 63 passengers and crew.

March 2, 1994. Continental Airlines Flight 795, with 110 passengers and six crew, aborts takeoff during a snowstorm when cockpit instruments malfunction. Seven people suffer minor injuries as the plane skids to a stop just 4 feet from Flushing Bay.

March 22, 1992. Twenty-seven people are killed and 24 injured when US Airways Flight 405, attempting to take off in a snowstorm, runs off the runway into Flushing Bay.

Sept. 20, 1989. Two people are killed when a US Airways Boeing 737 plane bound for Charlotte, North Carolina, with 62 people on board slides off the end of the runway into the East River during takeoff.

Jan. 31, 1982. Six passengers suffer cuts and bruises while making emergency exits from an Eastern Airlines Boeing 727 after the landing gear collapses on touchdown.

Feb. 1, 1957. Shortly after takeoff, a Northeast flight to Miami crashes on Rikers Island, killing 20

May 29, 1947. A United Airlines plane crashes through a fence during an aborted takeoff and catches


We're revamping our Comments section. Learn more and share your input.

More news