53° Good Morning
53° Good Morning
OpinionColumnistsMichael Dobie

Let New Yorkers settle the issues

Other states trust their residents to decide big questions, but Albany limits ballot proposals.

A view of a polling site during primary

A view of a polling site during primary election voting in New York on Sept. 13. Photo Credit: Justin Lane/EPA-EFE/REX/Shutterstock

Election Day is coming! And we have a bunch of interesting races in New York between candidates who excite or repel us. Control of the State Senate is up for grabs, and with it the possibility of single-party control.

But we’re missing out on some fun that voters have in other states. We’re not voting on any important issues, not directly. In some places, voters will weigh in on initiatives to fight climate change, expand Medicaid, change voting laws and legalize marijuana, among dozens of hot topics.

That’s because those states have laws encouraging such ballot measures. Not New York. Here, the State Legislature puts up a bond act every now and then. Every 20 years we get to decide whether to have a constitutional convention. Some local governments have ways to get proposals on ballots for their residents, like Brookhaven Town’s term limits proposition.

But statewide, New York is the pits.

There are 26 states that allow citizens to gather petitions to place proposed laws on a statewide ballot for fellow citizens to approve or reject. Not New York. Twenty-one of those states have a combined 68 measures initiated by citizens on this year’s ballots. Some states let their legislatures and various commissions or committees submit for voter approval proposals for new laws or constitutional amendments — dozens are on ballots this year alone.

In New York, long-reluctant lawmakers finally were browbeaten into putting up a constitutional amendment last year to strip pensions from officials convicted of corruption. It passed easily, with 73 percent approval. Now we’re back in proposition purgatory.

New York, New York, where the Bronx is up and the people are down, stymied by a legislature that often bottles up popular legislation and won’t let the public it claims to serve actually express its collective will by putting up bills to vote on.

This isn’t some new frustration. Gov. Mario Cuomo wanted to give citizens a mechanism to force lawmakers to vote on bills stuck in committee. Successor George Pataki supported letting citizens themselves use the petition process to put proposals on the ballot. Neither plan went anywhere; each required legislative approval.

Some citizen proposals become epic. Remember Proposition 13? That’s the California constitutional amendment approved in 1978 that limited property taxes and presaged the taxpayer revolt that spread across the country.

This year, New Yorkers won’t have a chance to vote to:

  • Legalize recreational marijuana. Voters in Michigan and North Dakota will.
  • Reduce prison sentences for nonviolent drug crimes. Voters in Ohio will.
  • Make redistricting less partisan. Voters in Missouri, Michigan, Colorado and Utah will.
  • Require that 50 percent of the state’s electricity be generated by wind or solar by 2030. Voters in Arizona and Nevada will.
  • Implement a fee on carbon dioxide emissions with the money to be used to reduce global warming. Voters in Washington will.
  • Limit the number of patients assigned to nurses. Voters in Massachusetts will.
  • Expand Medicaid as per provisions in Obamacare. Voters in Utah, Idaho, Nebraska and Montana will.

In Florida, voters will decide whether to give themselves the sole authority to approve casinos, increase the retirement age for judges to 75, restore voting rights for some felons who complete their sentences, and increase the amount of a home’s value exempted from property tax, among 13 measures.

The point isn’t whether you agree or disagree with any or all of these proposals. It’s that in some places you have a more direct way to participate in lawmaking and have your say on important issues.

But not in New York.

Michael Dobie is a member of Newsday’s editorial board


We're revamping our Comments section. Learn more and share your input.