47° Good Morning
47° Good Morning

Wrong move by alternative pride parade in Chicago

Decision on use of Star of David discriminatory.

Credit: iStock

Pride parades are some of the most inclusive events one could participate in. That is, unless you display your Jewish faith at a pride parade in Chicago.

At the alternative pride parade Chicago Dyke March, participants were kicked out for holding rainbow pride flags emblematized with a Jewish star, or Star of David, to highlight the intersection of LGBT identities and Judaism. Parade organizers said the people were removed because the march is a pro-Palestine environment, and a Jewish star can be regarded as a sign of Zionism and Palestinian occupation.

The events that took place Sunday, though, send a clear message: If you’re Jewish, and you put that Jewishness on display, you are not welcome.

While the Israeli-Palestinian conflict will always cause tensions, conflating a religious symbol with a foreign government’s actions is wrong. The march is billed as a more inclusive event than traditional pride parades, yet ironically was the only event held during pride celebrations that outwardly excluded people because of their use of a religious symbol. We have to recognize that the people who took these anti-Semitic actions were largely the same people who will rally against the alt-right, and any sort of Muslim travel ban. But what they did is no better.

As a Jewish college student, I’ve seen liberal groups on my George Washington University campus argue that university ties to Israel makes Palestinian students and pro-Palestine students feel unsafe. But many times, that conversation turns into Jewish students being told that they are responsible for these feelings. Regardless of anyone’s take on Israeli-Palestinian relations, a person shouldn’t be targeted or forced to answer for something because of his or her religion. Those on the alt-right are wrong to burden all Muslims with the actions of terrorist Muslim groups. And those on the extreme left are wrong to discriminate against Jews because of Israel’s politics.

A Jewish star represents a faith, not a country. And we should be allowed to march with that faith on display, especially at an event that celebrates inclusion.

Melissa Holzberg is an intern with Newsday Opinion.


We're revamping our Comments section. Learn more and share your input.