26° Good Evening
26° Good Evening

Needed: A bold vision for the MTA

Commuters at the Hicksville LIRR Train Station make

Commuters at the Hicksville LIRR Train Station make their way across the train platform during the evening rush hour September 5, 2018. Credit: Newsday / Thomas A. Ferrara

Wanted: A Miracle Worker.

The Metropolitan Transportation Authority’s financial picture is a disastrous mix of declining revenue from lower ridership and enormous looming expenses. Complaints about commuter rail service and the subways are endless. Amid all this misery, the MTA is also looking for a new leader.

It’s been a week since Joseph Lhota resigned as chairman, a departure that left a big hole. At Thursday’s MTA board meeting, officials unveiled a dismal budget picture and the potential for big fare and toll hikes, underscoring how critical the appointment of his successor will be.

Lhota came to the MTA in June 2017, at a low point for the agency. He successfully handled the Long Island Rail Road’s so-called “summer of hell,” and the creation of a subway action plan. He didn’t make magic, but he did stop some bleeding. Perhaps his most noteworthy accomplishment is bringing in solid leaders to oversee each of the MTA’s arms — the LIRR, New York City Transit and Metro-North. Phil Eng, Andy Byford and Cathy Rinaldi have shown they can make tough decisions and plan for the future.

But ultimately, the new chair, appointed by Gov. Andrew M. Cuomo and confirmed by the State Senate, will have to steer the MTA through the dark, twisting tunnels ahead.

It’ll help if the MTA’s next leader takes on a combined chair/chief executive role as a full-time job with a salary. That would open the gig up to a far wider pool of talent, and would allow whoever’s chosen to devote the time required to the enormous job at hand.

The next chief will have the unenviable task of digging the authority out of its financial mess and finding significant new funding streams, while overseeing plans to upgrade service and completing key projects like the LIRR’s third track and East Side Access. Then there’s the broader need to overhaul the Byzantine bureaucracy’s expensive and inefficient way of doing business, from contracts to construction to the organization’s culture. The job requires a deft political touch and the willingness to take responsibility, and make sure others do, too.

The chair has to act as both advocate for and critic of the organization and have a willingness to change anything and everything. Partnering with Amtrak on Penn Station’s redevelopment and East River tunnel repairs is key. While transit experience is prefered, even more important is the ability to manage a huge organization, and its finances.

Why not a worldwide search for an innovator in how to move people? After all, some of the best transit systems aren’t in the United States.

Once a new MTA chair is chosen, he — or she — must be given the latitude to transform the authority into an organization that delivers world-class service, while providing new funding other than the farebox. We need a vision for a flexible, modern transit system that can respond to its riders, and get them moving.

The editorial board


We're revamping our Comments section. Learn more and share your input.