TODAY'S PAPER
Scattered Clouds 37° Good Afternoon
Scattered Clouds 37° Good Afternoon
OpinionLetters

Letters: Snowden case draws conflicting reactions

Joseph Gordon-Levitt stars as controversial CIA whistle-blower Edward

Joseph Gordon-Levitt stars as controversial CIA whistle-blower Edward Snowden in "Snowden," based on true events and directed by Oliver Stone. With Shailene Woodley, Nicolas Cage and more. In theaters Sept. 16. Photo Credit: Open Road Films via YouTube

In one of my favorite fake commercials on “Saturday Night Live,” a couple argued over whether new Shimmer was a dessert topping or a floor wax. Obviously, it couldn’t be both, right?

A bipartisan congressional committee has unanimously concluded that Edward Snowden put “Americans at risk” [“Panel: Snowden’s leaks don’t make him whistleblower,” News, Sept. 16]. A committee member stated that Snowden betrayed his country. A Justice Department representative said, “Mr. Snowden is not a whistleblower. He is accused of leaking classified information.”

Apparently, they reason, he can’t be a whistleblower because he’s a traitor. It seems like they’re saying, we did nothing wrong because he did something worse. So is the government now damaging national security because, in response to a nonexistent whistleblower, it changed its surveillance policies?

What could the American people conclude? Maybe we should look to Chevy Chase and the “SNL” commercial for guidance: “Wait, you’re both right! New Shimmer is a dessert topping, and a floor wax!”

Christopher Paul, Bayport

 

When someone is entrusted with sensitive information, he or she should be held accountable. If Edward Snowden felt it was important enough to violate that trust, he should have taken legal steps to compel the government to disclose.

He violated the law. He committed a crime and should be held accountable. Many brave citizens have resorted to civil disobedience to fight what they felt was unjust. Snowden didn’t; instead he ran away. Snowden is a coward. He definitely isn’t a hero.

Michael Shapiro, Merrick

Columns