Think for a second before answering, all you parents reading. Would you be happier if you never had kids?

Well, maybe not on the second Sunday in May or the third one in June. But numerous studies have found that parents were indeed less happy -- and more depressed and had worse marriages -- than nonparents. Harvard psychologist Daniel Gilbert wrote in his book "Stumbling on Happiness" that an act of parenting makes most people about as happy as an act of housework.

But two new studies, presented this month at the Population Association of America's annual meeting, call those earlier results into question. Despite the whoops of joy when the camp bus pulls away and the awesome stillness of an empty nest, this new research suggests that parents today are indeed happier for the choice they made.

Yet, just once, I'd like to get through a whole week feeling I did an excellent job of being a mother. By "excellent" I mean feeling 100 percent free of the possibility that my nurturing -- either lax or tyrannical or ignorant -- was the root cause of any insecurity or misstep experienced by my two daughters.

As long as I'm fantasizing, if those seven days could also pass without my being the subject of their eye rolling, that would be kind of nice, too.

You would think after four decades on the job, a person could speak with authority about it. I could do that about being a friend or a writer or even a wife. But a mother . . . not so much. There are just too many miraculous attributes required, demanding we protect and defend, 24/7, like Marines, from the moment we're aware of conception till our own lives end.

The spur-of-the-moment, fly-by-the-seat-of-your-pantness of it all demands we relinquish any claims to peace of mind. Warm, comforting laps and healing kisses are supposed to magically appear, without the benefit of any basic training. It's no wonder comments like, "Because I said so," and "I'm going to break every bone in your body," come out of the mouths of the most reasonable of us.

advertisement | advertise on newsday


By virtue of its overwhelming demands, mothering is the role in which we make the most mistakes. Some we get away with; some we're haunted by for decades. At every stage -- toilet training to table manners, sex education to explaining death -- we are doing things for the first time, teaching more successfully as we learn what works.

Ironically, most of my friends and I believe we are better mothers than ours were. In fact, we get insulted when compared to the women who raised us, even as we echo their words. While the aprons, thimbles and ironing boards of my mother's generation were nowhere to be found in my home, there were a few behaviors that spewed out naturally under both our roofs.

I remember spitting on a tissue to clean a repulsed child's face, putting my hand out for chewed-up God knows what, and turning beyond red with frustration dealing with wet, knotted shoelaces. After hours of earnest dedication, both my mother's kids and my own had the weakest school costumes. Each of us checked our daughters' horoscopes daily, right after our own. And together we were in possession of a glance so withering it was known to elicit confessions and apologies instantly.

I remembering being terrified that my No. 1 child would always be so. A firstborn is, after all, the one you love the longest, the original experimental model. The children to follow are the kids with the sparse baby books.

A few decades into the job I learned each child in the family has a different mother, not better or worse, just different. The years taught me that my "No. 1 child" constantly changed, depending on who needed me most at that moment. The one with the fever, the one who didn't get into the sorority, the one who got tragically disappointing SATs.

The favorite then is the child you feel closest to at that moment, because no one can soothe her better than you. You love this child the fiercest because in that instant, all your manipulations, criticisms and pointed remarks are forgiven, understood as being part of the collateral damage that comes along with taking on an impossible job.

Nurturing, like exercise, is never ending -- and it comes equipped with a constantly raised bar. Sacrifice wins out over ambivalence and exhaustion, whether you're giving your kid that last piece of cake you covet or spending years' worth of vacation money on tuition.

In return for this taken-for-granted magnanimity, we mothers withstand long periods of being hated. We handle the shock of seeing how ungracious our kids can sometimes be. And we live with the almost unbearable worry about their future in this frightening world.


advertisement | advertise on newsday

'Ah, but when it works" was a bumper sticker on my neighbor's old Jaguar. Ah, but when the lessons of loyalty and devotion you would have sworn were ignored are reflected in your children's actions, when instinctively you come up with some bit of wisdom that saves the day, when you humbly sense you must be a much better mother than you thought to have raised such an incredible human being -- that's when you realize the rewards of being the best that you can be.

Do women without children have fewer wrinkles? Probably. Are the dozens of economists, psychologists, Harvard professors and Nobel Prize winners who have spent years quantifying how parents were less happy/more depressed/less satisfied than non-parents, right on the mark, at least a few times a year? Probably.

Would every parent I know, after reviewing every last statistic, chart and graph, do it all over again? Absolutely.

Marcia Byalick lives in Searingtown.