Good Morning
Good Morning

Harold Baines a controversial Hall of Fame selection  

Harold Baines cries during a news conference for

Harold Baines cries during a news conference for the Baseball Hall of Fame during the winter meetings on Monday in Las Vegas. Credit: AP/John Locher

LAS VEGAS — Harold Baines is aware many fans are questioning whether his credentials are worthy of the Hall of Fame. He’s not sweating.

“Well, they can’t take it away from me now, even if they don’t think I should be there,” he told The Associated Press.

A day after being elected to Cooperstown by a Hall-picked panel of 16, the six-time All-Star was at the winter meetings Monday for a news conference with newly chosen Lee Smith.

“I wasn’t out there beating my chest and campaigning for this,” Baines said. “I’m very honored and humbled.”

Shortly after being chosen, Baines said he certainly wasn’t anticipating this honor. “Very shocked,” he admitted.

So were many others around the baseball world.

In fact, in the hours after his selection was announced at the Mandalay Bay resort, a lot of conversations at the gathering started the exact same way: “Harold Baines?”

No one doubted Baines was a top player — 1,628 RBIs, 384 home runs and 2,866 hits.

“I had a great career," he said. "I’m very proud of it.”

But a couple other numbers stood out, too. Baines never drew more than 6.1 percent in five elections by the Baseball Writers’ Association of America, far from the 75 percent required. In the key WAR stat compiled by, Baines’ lifetime total was tied for 545th.

Yes, 545th.

Behind the likes of Placido Polanco, Jim Sundberg and Rafael Furcal in wins above replacement, not to mention Gil Hodges, Dick Allen, Don Mattingly, John Olerud and dozens more.

The vote by the Today’s Game Era Committee was sure to spark renewed cries of cronyism at Cooperstown. Especially because the 16-member panel appointed by the Hall board included longtime White Sox owner Jerry Reinsdorf.

“I’m glad he was on that committee this year to help to get into the Hall of Fame,” Baines said.

Baines spent nearly all of his first 10 seasons with the White Sox and serves as a team ambassador in their community relations department.

“So happy for Harold. He’s a great player and a great human being,” Reinsdorf said in a statement. “I am so honored that I was a member of the committee. He deserved to be in long ago. I am just so excited.”

He added Monday: “The numbers are there.”

Tony La Russa, Baines’ first big-league manager, also was on the panel that elected him.

In the past, Phil Rizzuto and Bill Mazeroski were among the players who benefited from friendly faces on Veterans Committees to reach the Hall. That panel has been revamped over the years, and the Today’s Game Era group was created as part of changes in 2014.

“The era committees were established as a sort of a court of appeals for an opportunity in the event that over time it was felt that maybe somebody slipped through the cracks,” Hall president Jeff Idelson said. “And in the case of someone who received 6 percent of the vote in the BBWAA election, the reason that may have happened could be for many, many reasons.”

It took 12 votes for election by the panel — Smith was unanimous, Baines got 12 and former outfielder and manager Lou Piniella fell just short with 11.

George Steinbrenner, Orel Hershiser, Albert Belle, Joe Carter, Will Clark, Davey Johnson and Charlie Manuel all received fewer than five votes.

Baines, 59, had a smooth, consistent, lefthanded stroke. But he never finished higher than ninth in an MVP vote, and never was among the top five AL hitters in the yearly batting race. His single-season high for home runs was 29 at a time when many players hit more.

As this vote approached, his name drew little to no buzz in debates over those who might be selected.

“I wasn’t expecting this day to come,” the career .289 hitter said.

Mattingly said he was happy for Baines, calling him a great hitter.

The Miami manager was a six-time All-Star, won nine Gold Gloves at first base for the Yankees and hit .307 lifetime. Mattingly was the 1985 AL MVP and four times finished in the top seven of the MVP voting.

Mattingly had 2,153 hits, 222 home runs and 1,099 RBIs in 14 seasons in a career limited by back trouble.

“I just didn’t play long enough,” he said Monday at the winter meetings. “Wasn’t able to stay healthy long enough to really put that pile of numbers together. So there was a period of time that I could hit with anybody and do things on the field at my position and with the bat that nobody was doing.

“When I think of myself, when you see Harold, played 22 years or something like that and you end up with a pile of numbers that grow and grow,” he said.

Baines became a designated hitter after knee trouble ended his days in the outfield, and DHs have struggled to gain backing from Hall voters. Baines joined Frank Thomas as the only players in the Hall who spent more than half his games as a DH.

“Everything I hear or read is DH is really not part of the game, I guess,” Baines said. “But I disagree. But maybe this will the open up the doors for some more DHs.”

Both closers and DHs could see the numbers increase again very shortly. Mariano Rivera is eligible for the first time and big-hitting DH Edgar Martinez will be back on the ballot when results of the next BBWAA election are announced Jan. 22.

Induction ceremonies are scheduled for July 21 at Cooperstown, New York.

Between now and then, there’s certain to be more discussion about who else should be in the Hall. Drug-tainted Barry Bonds and Roger Clemens are on the upcoming BBWAA ballot, influential players’ union head Marvin Miller has been denied seven times by various committees, and steroids user Mark McGwire wasn’t among Sunday’s candidates.

New York Sports