Robinson Cano walked and was sacrificed to second before Brett Gardner also walked. Thames, activated off the DL earlier in theday, received a postgame curtain call from what remained of the Independence Day crowd of 46,810.
DeWayne Wise hit a tying single off Rivera in the ninth and flubbed a catch to let the Yankees tie it on Gardner’s inside-the-park homer. Wise hit a go-ahead three-run homer in the fifth.
David Robertson (1-3) struck out Jose Molina to end the top of the 10th with a runner on third. Mark Teixeira hit a go-ahead double in the seventh, an inning after Brett Gardner tied it with an inside-the-park home run that was a result of Wise’s fielding blunder. Two runs scored on Gardner’s two-out drive to deep center after Wise appeared to lose the ball in the sun, falling down as the ball glanced off the top of his glove and rolled to the wall and allowing Gardner to scamper home.
The Blue Jays took a 4-3 lead on in the fifth inning on Wise’s three-run shot off the pole in right field.
Yankees starter Phil Hughes, announced as an All-Star before the game, allowed five runs in six innings.
Wise, nearly a year removed from the juggling, home-run robbing catch he made against the wall to preserve Buehrle’s perfect game in the ninth inning, put the Blue Jays up 4-3 before he let New York back in the game.
Shawn Camp, manager Cito Gaston’s most trusted middle reliever this season, allowed singles to Derek Jeter and Nick Swisher beforeTeixeira’s double down the right-field line put the Yankees ahead. Swisher was thrown out at home for the second time in the game onFrancisco Cervelli’s foul pop to right to end the inning.
The Yankees looked as if they’d get some runs back in the bottom of the fifth, but Nick Swisher was thrown out at home on Teixeira’sdeep double to center. Texieira was also out at the plate trying to come home after Alex Rodriguez popped out to shallow center on thefirst pitch.
Teixeira hit a tying sacrifice fly in the third before Rodriguez singled home another run. Ramiro Pena singled home a run in thefourth.