The following is a list of the 2009 Newsday All-Long Island Football players and where they have committed to play in college. Check back as the list will be updated.
 
If you are a coach or athletic director ONLY, and would like to update a player's status, please call 631-843-2820.
 
First team
 
Tom Schreiber, St. Anthony’s: Princeton (lacrosse)
John Kinder, Lawrence: Syracuse
Anthony Brunetti, Holy Trinity: C.W. Post
Davon Lawrence, Sachem North: Stony Brook
Kevin Allen, Freeport: C.W. Post
Michael Ehrhardt, Chaminade: Maryland (lacrosse)
Mike Gallo, Seaford: C.W. Post
Chris Richards, Farmingdale: Undecided
Matt Wilson, Holy Trinity: Maine
Bill Sweeney, Garden City: Undecided
Ryan Sloan, Bellport: Junior
Sean Moeller, East Islip: Undecided
Jevahn Cruz, Hills West: Stony Brook
Connor Horl, Garden City: Undecided
Rob Welsh, St. Anthony’s: Syracuse
Kevin Hauter, Floyd: Stony Brook
Malcom Cater, Riverhead: Syracuse
Stephen Jehelka, Garden City:  Junior
Jack Moorehead, Glenn: Undecided
Evan Kappatos, Syosset: Sophomore
Preshod McCoy, North Babylon: Junior
Mike Pellegrino, Connetquot: Junior
John McGibbon, Lindenhurst: Clemson (baseball)
Greg D’Arienzo, Carey: Maryland (lacrosse)
 
Second team
 
Tom DeNapoli, Lynbrook: Towson (lacrosse)
Alex Corporan, Brentwood: Undecided
Steve Skon, Lindenhurst: Junior
Dan Russo, Northport: Undecided
Ken Barnett, Lawrence: Undecided
Zack Losco, Hauppauge: UPenn (lacrosse)
Damarr Aultman, Hills West: Maine
Gene Garay, Oceanside: Junior
Chris Jean Pierre, Brentwood: Bowling Green (Priority walkon)
Golden Ukonu, North Babylon: Junior
Joe Kirchner, Sachem North: Cortland
Kevin McHale, Connetquot: M.I.T.
Mark Mazur, North Babylon: Undecided
Mike Lisi, Carey: Undecided
Dan Belfiore, Glen Cove: Undecided
Corey Bateman, Freeport: Undecided
Rob Burke, Wantagh: Undecided
Eric Schmitt, East Islip: Undecided
Ryan Crawley, North Babylon: Undecided
Andrew Hodge, Hills West: Undecided
Jawara Dudley, Roosevelt: Stony Brook
Kevin Lacey, Floyd: Undecided
Zenel Hudson, Bay Shore: Undecided
Nick Stover, Sayville: Undecided
Will Crapo, Plainedge: Undecided
Jesse Signa, St. Anthony's: Undecided