Good Morning
Good Morning

Doug Weight wants clarity on goaltender interference rule

Islanders head coach Doug Weight looks on against

Islanders head coach Doug Weight looks on against the Capitals at Barclays Center on Thursday. Credit: Kathleen Malone-Van Dyke

Add Doug Weight to the ever-growing list of those seeking some semblance of clarity on what is and what is not goalie interference.

The hot button topic will be on the agenda, and will likely dominate the discussions, at the NHL general managers meeting Monday through Wednesday at Boca Raton, Florida.

The Islanders coach was still red hot after Friday night’s 6-3 loss at Washington where he lost his challenge on Alex Chiasson’s power-play goal that made it 4-1 at 1:46 of the third period.

Before Chiasson knocked in a loose puck in the crease, Jakub Vrana skated across the top of the blue arc and made contact with goalie Jaroslav Halak, who seemed to get spun out of position.

To Weight, the play was very, very similar to the apparent goal Penguins defenseman Brian Dumoulin had overturned as he was called for goalie interference in a 5-2 loss at Toronto this past Saturday.

Dumoulin did make contact with Maple Leafs goalie Frederik Andersen but after being pushed by Toronto defenseman Ron Hainsey.

“It’s a challenge that the league has to try to iron out,” Penguins coach Mike Sullivan said after that game. “I know it’s being discussed and everybody is going to try to do their best to clarify the language, clarify the criteria. Right now, I don’t think anyone really knows what is goalie interference and what isn’t.”

Sullivan could not challenge the play because Dumoulin was penalized. So instead of the Penguins cutting their deficit to 3-1, the Maple Leafs scored on the ensuing power play to make it 4-0.

“Does that not look exactly like the Dumoulin goal?” a frustrated Weight said as he brought up Chiasson’s goal unprompted during his post-game media scrum on Friday.

“He comes across the crease, he spins the goalie,” Weight added. “I thought it was a goal when Dumoulin scored. They were exactly the same. Exactly.”

The issue is, has been and will likely continue to be, goalie interference is a completely subjective call.

“I feel like it’s a good goal but I don’t know what is and what isn’t,” said Weight of Dumoulin’s goal, but he challenged the Chiasson goal based on the ruling about Dumoulin.

Referees Francois St. Laurent and Dan O’Rourke immediately discussed the play with Weight. Not that it clarified anything for Weight.

“They were kind about coming over and talking about it,” Weight said. “I think there’s a lot of confusion so that’s tough. I don’t like to talk about it. But it’s frustrating for us.”

Now, the question becomes what changes, if any, will come about when the general managers talk about the topic this week.

And if any changes are made, will they be made for this postseason?

Many around the league would like that, though it seems highly unlikely that would happen.

It could be that instead of the on-ice officials making the ruling upon video review, off-ice officials at the NHL war room in Toronto are put in charge.

But what’s needed most is a clear-cut definition of what constitutes goalie interference, likely entailing a rewriting or clarification of the rule book.

This much is sure: It will be very difficult to accomplish.

Weight, though, is certainly rooting for more clarity.


Being interviewed by MSG analyst Stan Fischler often takes a bit of concentration on the player’s behalf.

Let well-spoken defenseman Thomas Hickey explain:

“It’s funny, he doesn’t always ask questions. He makes a statement,” Hickey said of Fischler, 86, retiring from Islanders’ broadcasts following this season after working MSG Networks since 1975 and having seen his first hockey game in 1939.

“It’s always true and he’s looking for a comment on it or for you to elaborate,” Hickey added. “Sometimes, he’s got a little catch phrase that takes you a couple of seconds to click in. Sometimes, you’ve just got to pretend you know what he’s talking about.”


The Islanders’ season may be crumbling — actually, it has and is now just limping to its conclusion — but new dad Casey Cizikas’ mood couldn’t be better.

Jack William Cizikas’ birth was induced just before the Islanders departed for a 10-day trip that took them to Pittsburgh, Vancouver, Edmonton and Calgary, returning to Long Island on Monday.

“Right now, it’s kind of nice to get away from the rink and not think about hockey for a second,” said Cizikas. “He’s the only thing on my mind and when I come to the rink, I’m kind of recharged, I’m kind of refreshed. I haven’t been sitting at home thinking what if I did this, what if I did that? He kind of doesn’t really do much right now, he kind of just lies around. But it’s exciting. It’s a lot of fun.”


The Islanders are likely to miss the playoffs for the second straight season. Here are the NHL’s longest playoff droughts:

Carolina Hurricanes — 2009

Buffalo Sabres — 2011

New Jersey Devils — 2012

Arizona Coyotes — 2012

Colorado Avalanche — 2014

New York Sports