Two goalies in an altercation near center ice? Sounds familiar.
But the sharp elbow that Senators backup Robin Lehner delivered to Poulin didn't have nearly the same effect as Johnson's blow, which will sideline DiPietro for four to six weeks with facial fractures.
The foolish penalty - taken with both teams exiting the ice at the end of the second period - gave the Islanders a two-man advantage to begin the third and led to the winning goal in their 5-3 win over Ottawa Saturday night.
Rob Schremp scored two goals, including the clincher, in the Islanders' feisty victory. With Lehner pulled and the Senators already on the power play, Frans Nielsen added an empty-net goal on the penalty-kill with nine seconds left to seal the win.
"It was kind of a bad penalty for their goalie to take and it was good to make him pay for it," said Schremp, who laughed when asked if he was surprised by Lehner's actions. "It's kind of childish,'' he said. "We used to do that in Pee Wees when we were pouting. I didn't think it was really necessary."
Lehner, who replaced Brian Elliott to begin the second, told reporters after the game that he was provoked by Poulin. "I was going off and came around the Islander guy - I don't know the name of the goalie - but he skates against me and starts screaming at me,'' Lehner said. "I put my shoulder into him and he falls easily on his back. It wasn't an elbow, that's for sure."
"I didn't say anything," countered Poulin, who said he was glad he stayed composed. "It was frustrating, but I kept my mind in the hockey game and they didn't score in the third."
Tensions already were high before that play. With the score tied at 3, a brawl erupted near the Senators' net late in the second. John Tavares and the Senators' Milan Michalek earned four minutes each for roughing and Andrew MacDonald was given a 10-minute misconduct.
Matt Moulson, who also was involved in the fracas, was incensed to see his friend and linemate Tavares punched in the back of the head by Michalek.
"It was a guy taking advantage of someone in a defenseless position," said Moulson, who scored the game's first goal at 4:10 of the first. "I was mad. I thought it was questionable that [Michalek] didn't get an extra penalty on it. I guess he got away with it."
Entering the game, Poulin had given up only one goal in each of his previous two starts, but he gave up three goals on the first five shots he faced.
But after the Islanders and Senators traded goals three times in the first period - Michael Grabner also tallied for the Islanders - Poulin was poised in the final 40 minutes. He made 20 saves to lead the Islanders to their second win in three games.
"It's been his strength,'' coach Jack Capuano said. "He's a confident kid. He wants to be that guy. It's a tough position to play."
Seeing Poulin go down was enough to make the Islanders cringe. With Dwayne Roloson traded and DiPietro and Nathan Lawson out with injuries, Poulin essentially is the last line of defense. Capuano, however, thinks Lawson (MCL strain, left knee) is only a week from returning.
Mikko Koskinen, a 6-6 Finnish prospect, was called up yesterday morning from Bridgeport to back up Poulin.