Erol's Chit Chat Cafe

Menemem -- eggs with green peppers, onions and

Menemem -- eggs with green peppers, onions and tomatoes -- at Erol's Chit Chat Cafe. (May 23, 2012) (Credit: Kathy Kmonicek)

Location info

Erol's Chit Chat Cafe in Port Jefferson Station

1597 Rte. 112 Port Jefferson Station, NY 11776

Erol's Chit Chat Cafe description New to Port Jefferson Station is a Turkish restaurant with the unlikely name of Erol’s ... More »

Related media

Turkish coffee with a serving of Turkish delight Erol's Chit Chat Cafe

Travel deals

A dining space outfitted with handsome wood chairs and tables is -- surprisingly -- embedded within a Turkish-American grocery store. In one corner, there's a big-screen TV, easy chairs and a coffee table. You can even get Wi-Fi. Erol's Chit Chat Cafe was made for multitaskers.

Eating was all I cared about the evening I was shown to a table within view of the olive oil, pudding mixes, nectarine juice and tea.

Surprisingly, the breadbasket was filled with reheated Italian bread instead of pita, which, I was told, was reserved for appetizers. Some warmed-up pita strips did come with the fine tahini-scented hummus and smoky baba ghanoush. Ezme, a spicy -- but not fiery -- blend of chopped vegetables, had depth of flavor. In comforting counterpoint was a big, fluffy zucchini pancake, made with mint, dill, feta and mozzarella.

Chef Bora Pala is a whiz at marinating and grilling meat. White meat chicken kebabs, all too often dry and overcooked, were moist, bursting with savory juices. So, too, the lamb kebabs. A big hit was Pala's Adana kebab, ground spiced lamb skewered and grilled. Juicier yet was his kofte kebab, ingeniously seasoned little grilled ground beef patties. A vegetarian alternative, grilled vegetable Iskender kebab, made with yogurt, sliced pita and tomato sauce, had a saucy appeal, if not quite in the same league.

Service here can be puzzling. At lunch, eaten at an outdoor table overlooking the parking lot, I requested a sandwich on pita and was told I could only get a panino, hero, wrap or quesadilla. This at a Turkish restaurant? In a later phone conversation, Pala insisted pita sandwiches were always available.

But things worked out for the better, since I ended up ordering an egg dish called menemen, a delectable loose scramble of eggs, tomatoes, peppers and onions. How I wish it were a staple on every breakfast menu.

For dessert, there's house-made baklava, kunefe, a warm shredded wheat and cheese pastry, and my favorite, kazandibi, an airy creamy custard with a burnt-sugar topping.

Although it may not be fully evolved, Erol's Chit Chat Cafe has the potential to be a neighborhood nexus.

advertisement | advertise on newsday

Newsday on social media

@Newsday

advertisement | advertise on newsday