Of the 23 Long Island hospitals ranked by The Leapfrog Group,...

Of the 23 Long Island hospitals ranked by The Leapfrog Group, a safety-focused nonprofit, 14 scored top marks for patient safety. Credit: Newsday Photos

Fourteen Long Island hospitals scored top marks for patient safety in a national report published Wednesday.

Only three of the 23 Long Island hospitals ranked by The Leapfrog Group, a safety-focused nonprofit, received C grades in patient safety, based on how well they protected patients from accidents, infections and injuries. Only one Long Island hospital — Nassau University Medical Center — scored a D, down from a C in Leapfrog's fall 2025 ratings.

The Leapfrog Group’s rankings can help Long Islanders evaluate hospitals for some visits, but it’s important that prospective patients look at multiple reports — particularly recent reports — and consider costs and their health insurance, said Patricia Kelmar, senior director of health care campaigns for the consumer advocacy group PIRG, headquartered in Denver, Colorado.

“You always want to see the most recent report and understand and know what that covers,” Kelmar said. “Patient safety and quality has to be a daily priority for leadership in a hospital.”

The Washington, D.C.-based Leapfrog evaluated 2,367 hospitals nationwide, with 900, or about 38%, receiving A grades, according to a news release from the nonprofit.

“We want all our hospitals to get As,” said Elisabeth Benjamin, vice president of health initiatives at the Manhattan-based Community Service Society of New York. “It means that the standard of care is improving.”

Of the Long Island hospitals rated, seven A-grade hospitals were in Northwell Health’s network. Those hospitals are Glen Cove Hospital, Huntington Hospital, Mather Hospital in Port Jefferson, Plainview Hospital and Syosset Hospital.

North Shore University Hospital and South Shore University hospital — also Northwell Hospitals — both received A grades, up from B grades in Leapfrog’s spring 2026 report.

Chief quality officer for Northwell Health Peter Silver attributed the improvement at those two hospitals to lower infection rates, fewer complications from surgery and medications, and generally improved patient safety.

“We want to always be doing better and always be sure we’re providing the best care possible to our patients,” Silver said. “I think these results reinforce that our strategy is working.”

Three of Northwell’s hospitals, Long Island Jewish Medical Center, Long Island Jewish Valley Stream and Peconic Bay Medical Center in Riverhead, received B grades. Peconic Bay Medical center dropped in the ratings from an A grade in the spring.

Whether a hospital’s safety rating has improved or declined can help Long Islanders evaluate whether a hospital is investing in safety, Kelmar said.

“The history of the organization and the grades that they've had over time is a really important piece of the puzzle,” Kelmar said. “Hospitals are run by human beings, and sometimes they're short on staff, there's a senior leadership change, or any number of things could cause a breakdown in their patient safety protocols.”

Patients with doctors who can work out of multiple hospitals can also press their physician on what hospitals are safer, Kelmar added. Long Islanders can also examine the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services star ratings system and New York State’s hospital profiles, Benjamin added. 

NYU Langone Hospital—Long Island and NYU Langone Hospital—Suffolk both maintained an A and B rating respectively from the spring.

Joseph Greco, executive vice president and chief of hospital operations for NYU Langone Hospital—Long Island in Mineola, said the health system has invested in NYU Langone Hospital—Suffolk since taking it over. NYU Langone completed its merger with Long Island Community Hospital, now NYU Langone Hospital—Suffolk, last year, Newsday reported.

“We’re seeing the progress that we have in all our hospitals take hold in Suffolk County,” Greco said.

Mount Sinai South Nassau also received an A grade, the same as its spring score. The A grade comes after the hospital completed a $10 million expansion at the Oceanside hospital and opened five new operating rooms, Newsday reported.

“This has been a journey that we have taken very seriously,” said Alan Wong, chief medical officer at Mount Sinai South Nassau. “This grade represents everyone at the hospital pulling together, working towards high quality care for our patients.”

St. Joseph Hospital, a part of Catholic Health Long Island, received an A grade for Leapfrog’s fall 2026 report, up from a B in the spring 2026 report.

“Catholic Health is driven by a culture that places patient safety at the center of everything we do," Jason Golbin, executive vice president and chief medical officer at Catholic Health, said in a statement.

Also in Catholic Health’s network, Mercy Hospital in Rockville Centre, St. Catherine of Siena Hospital in Smithtown, St. Charles Hospital in Port Jefferson and St. Francis Hospital and Heart Center all received A grades, while Good Samaritan Hospital scored a C — the same as its spring 2026 score.

The Leapfrog Group gave two other hospitals on Long Island C grades: Stony Brook Eastern Long Island Hospital and Stony Brook University Hospital, which had scored a C in Leapfrog’s spring 2026 report. The Leapfrog Group did not grade Stony Brook Eastern Long Island Hospital in the spring.

Stony Brook Southampton hospital scored a B, up from a C in Leapfrog's spring 2026 report. Eric Morley, chief quality officer at Stony Brook Medicine, said in an emailed statement that the health system "constantly strive[s] for continuous improvement to achieve the best outcomes," and noted it had achieved high marks by other ranking systems.

Nassau University Medical Center was the only Long Island Hospital to receive a D rating, according to the Leapfrog Group. 

NUMC serves a large number of patients on public insurance, and its debts reached $1.4 billion in 2025, Newsday reported.

NUMC leadership is working on a plan, due Dec. 1, to improve the facility’s finances, Newsday reported. Hospital leadership is considering building a new facility, rather than spending millions on repairs, Newsday reported.

Representatives for NUMC did not immediately respond to requests for comment.

A D grade is concerning, but Leah Binder, the president and CEO of the Leapfrog Group, encouraged prospective patients to do additional research and ask their physician about safety practices.

“If you see a hospital got a D, you can dig in and look at how they did on all 32 measures” that Leapfrog examines, Binder said. “Then you can ask some questions.”

U.S. loses its measles-free status ... October's LI home prices are out ... Holiday gift guide Credit: Newsday

Two LI men convicted in murder of teacher ... U.S. loses its measles-free status ... Town, city healthcare costs rise ... Working Moms: Making friends

U.S. loses its measles-free status ... October's LI home prices are out ... Holiday gift guide Credit: Newsday

Two LI men convicted in murder of teacher ... U.S. loses its measles-free status ... Town, city healthcare costs rise ... Working Moms: Making friends

Subscribe

Unlimited Digital AccessOnly 25¢for 6 months

SUBSCRIBESALE ENDS SOON | CANCEL ANYTIME