The Optimum operational center in Bethpage, Oct. 29.

The Optimum operational center in Bethpage, Oct. 29. Credit: Debbie Egan-Chin

A Suffolk resident has filed a potential class-action lawsuit against Optimum Communications, Inc., alleging the internet provider's use of "network enhancement fees" deceives customers about the true price of its internet services.

The complaint, filed by plaintiff Bradley Dichter, of Nesconset, on Monday  says that the combined claims of class members could exceed $5 million, with thousands of Optimum customers eligible for relief. The suit, filed in the United States District Court for the Eastern District of New York, calls for injunctive relief to stop Optimum from continuing its allegedly deceptive advertising that omits the network enhancement fee, alongside monetary damages. 

"Optimum continues to invest in our network, including bringing fiber internet to more than 3 million homes, and we give customers great value across our full suite of products," Optimum wrote in a statement to Newsday when asked about the class action lawsuit. "We take customer concerns seriously and remain focused on delivering the best possible experience."

Potential classes

The complaint has three claims for relief: one alleging violations of New York State law barring abusive business conduct, one alleging a violation of New York false advertising law, and a third alleging that Optimum has been unjustly enriched because of its alleged conduct.

    WHAT NEWSDAY FOUND

  • A lawsuit that seeks class-action status has been filed against Optimum Communications, Inc. for allegedly deceiving customers with "network enhancement fees."

  • The lawsuit alleges that Optimum's advertising omits the mandatory fee, misleading consumers about the true cost of internet services.

  • Thousands of consumers could be eligible members of the class and the complaint alleges that combined damages could be over $5 million.

The case has two potential defined classes; one for nationwide customers and one for New York customers. The two classes include all Optimum Internet customers who were charged a "Network Enhancement Fee" on or after Nov. 13, 2023.

Most class actions are opt-out cases, so consumers eligible for potential relief are automatically included unless they request to be excluded, according to the legal information website ClassAction.org. Once a case settles, class members must file a claim form online or by mail by the settlement deadline to receive compensation.

Fee disclosures

Optimum charges customers a mandatory "network enhancement fee" on top of the advertised monthly price for its internet service, according to the complaint. Optimum advertises to customers a flat monthly rate for internet services, the complaint states, but the company adds a $6 fee to customers' monthly bill separately from the monthly internet charge.

Optimum does not disclose the fee when customers purchase their services, Dichter's complaint alleges. The suit states that Dichter did not discover the fee until he received his monthly bill.

"The only price that consumers consider and rely upon when conducting price comparisons with similar service providers is the internet service's advertised price," the complaint reads. "Reasonable consumers cannot be expected to ferret out these hidden fees."

Dichter is represented by a coalition of three law firms, New York City’s Reese LLP, Washington, D.C.'s KalielGold PLLC and Arkansas’s Jennings & Earley PLLC. None of the law firms responded to a Newsday request for comment. 

Consumer impact

Consumers tend to anchor on the first price they see for a product, Columbia University Business School professor Vicki G. Morwitz said in an interview with Newsday. A consumer is unlikely to change their buying decision after a hidden price is revealed, Morwitz said, often assuming that other internet providers will have similar charges.

She believes hidden fees make it harder for an honest business to compete, since they can appear more expensive than competitors that use additional mandatory fees to artificially lower the monthly price.

The fee also allows Optimum to raise its prices while appearing to honor the original monthly cost, according to the complaint. Court documents allege that Optimum raised the network charge from $2.50 to $6 but the complaint does not specify when this price increase occurred.

"Consumers will be more willing to accept a price increase if it's hidden in a surcharge," Morwitz said.

Class-action status

This is not the first time Optimum’s billing practices have drawn scrutiny. The Attorney General of Connecticut filed a lawsuit in 2024 against Optimum over the use of network enhancement fees, alleging that they deceive customers. The case is still ongoing. 

Optimum settled a class-action lawsuit over network enhancement fees and other similar charges in 2023 in the Superior Court of New Jersey by creating a settlement fund worth up to $15 million, according to court documents.

Successful class-action lawsuits do not always lead to companies changing their behavior, co-director of the Case Western Reserve University Center for Business Law Eric C. Chaffee said in an interview. A company may decide the profit from the alleged illegal activity is worth the cost of a class-action lawsuit, Chaffee said, and business people also may not realize that the alleged activity is unlawful. 

"A lot of settlement agreements don't actually involve an acknowledgment of wrongdoing," Chafee said. "It may simply just be that one side has agreed to pay x number of dollars for this particular issue to go away."

Working Moms: Finding your 'village' ... Out East: Bedell Cellars ... HS plays of the week Credit: Newsday

One town's budget about-face ... See the highest paid educators on LI ... What's in store with the weather ... Out East: Bedell Cellar

Working Moms: Finding your 'village' ... Out East: Bedell Cellars ... HS plays of the week Credit: Newsday

One town's budget about-face ... See the highest paid educators on LI ... What's in store with the weather ... Out East: Bedell Cellar

Subscribe

Unlimited Digital AccessOnly 25¢for 6 months

SUBSCRIBESALE ENDS SOON | CANCEL ANYTIME