A Christmas display where families can get their picture taken...

A Christmas display where families can get their picture taken with Santa at Smith Haven Mall in Lake Grove. The mall has undergone renovations to enhance customers' experiences and options. Credit: Thomas Hengge

Smith Haven Mall’s multimillion-dollar renovation, which puts more focus on socialization inside and outside the building, should be done in time for the biggest shopping day of the year, an official said.

About 98% of the work at the Lake Grove property is finished, as final touches are being made to wrap up the project in the week leading up to Black Friday, said Mathew Boals, the mall's general manager.

The mall needed a refresh to meet customers’ current retail expectations, he said.

"If you were here before, we had an older-style green and yellow mall, and now we’re into a more modern look … a better environment for shopping — just a cleaner, fresher look for the customer,” he said.

WHAT NEWSDAY FOUND

  • Smith Haven Mall’s multimillion-dollar renovation should be done in time for the biggest shopping day of the year, Black Friday, an official said.
  • The renovation included turning an existing courtyard into an outdoor plaza to encourage visitors to linger; upgrading flooring, entryways and the food court’s appearance; and adding new stores, restaurants, paint, signs and fixtures to the overall property.
  • The upgrade of the mall’s courtyard is part of a trend at retail properties across Long Island and nationwide, as landlords create or enhance outside spaces for socialization.

The mall’s owner, Indianapolis-based Simon Property Group Inc., started renovation work in summer 2025 that included turning an existing courtyard into an outdoor plaza to encourage visitors to linger; upgrading flooring, entryways and the food court’s appearance; and adding new stores, restaurants, paint, signs and fixtures to the property.

Even Santa has new digs, since the more than 20-year-old "castle” set for photos with Saint Nick has been replaced by a ring of Christmas trees and oversized ornaments.

The mall’s makeover also included replacing an indoor children’s play area with a larger activity center beside the entrance of tenant Stony Brook Medicine Advanced Specialty Care, whose affiliate, Stony Brook Children’s Hospital, sponsored the play area.

The food court upgrades included new seating and group gathering places, while the furniture in common areas in hallways was replaced with "more modern, sleeker-looking” furnishings, Boals said.

Smith Haven Mall introduced an open-air area called the Lifestyle Courtyard in 2006 and 2007.

The recent renovation project turned that courtyard into an outdoor plaza, which opened Oct. 30 with lounge furniture, game areas and cabana-style seating with café tables and umbrellas, as well as green turf that replaced concrete, Simon said.

Plaza invites activity

The new outdoor area at Smith Haven Mall in Lake...

The new outdoor area at Smith Haven Mall in Lake Grove Friday. Credit: Thomas Hengge

The plaza has attracted more activity outside, Boals said.

"We've seen people playing soccer, playing hacky sack. And then we have a lot of the Stony Brook Medicine folks are out here enjoying their lunch, taking a break from the stressful work that they do,” he said.

New tenants at the mall include accessories retailer Coach, which returned to the property in October, and clothing store Abercrombie & Fitch returned this month.

Chinese soup dumpling eatery Ugly Dumpling and clothing retailer Zara opened at the mall in September, and Boxcar Burgers opened in the food court in June.

Toy and home goods retailer Miniso, toy store Pop Mart, men’s clothing store Jack & Jones, and clothing store Goat USA will open before the end of this year, Boals said.

Also, LongHorn Steakhouse is under construction in a freestanding building that a Bahama Breeze restaurant vacated in May 2025.

LongHorn will open in winter 2027, a spokeswoman told Newsday in September, but she declined to say whether the opening would be early or late in the year.

Built in 1969, the 1.2 million-square-foot Smith Haven Mall straddles Lake Grove and Smithtown. Located at 313 Smith Haven Mall, near the intersection of Middle Country and New Moriches roads, the mall has more than 130 stores. Its anchor tenants include Primark, Macy’s, H&M and Dick’s Sporting Goods.

Smith Haven Mall’s renovation is a multimillion-dollar project, according to Simon, which declined to disclose the specific amount.

Simon owns two other Long Island malls — Roosevelt Field in Uniondale and Walt Whitman Shops in Huntington Station.

Getting outside

Smith Haven Mall is a high-performing property, with a class A rating, according to Green Street, a Newport Beach, California-based real estate information provider.

As of Dec. 31, the mall’s occupancy rate was 99.5%, according to Simon's annual report, published in February.

Simon’s upgrade of the mall’s courtyard is part of a trend at retail properties across Long Island and nationwide.

"Landlords are adding outdoor space to draw more visitors and keep them longer, in the hope that they spend more and increase sales,” said David Caputo, a data scientist at Moody’s Analytics, a financial intelligence provider in Manhattan.

Some landlords are turning enclosed malls partially or completely into open-air shopping centers with street-facing storefronts and green spaces.

Not only are open-air facilities cheaper to maintain, but they also give landlords a way to reuse vacant anchor store spaces, Caputo said in an email.

Loading video…

2 charged, 2 hurt in stabbing at NCC ... Acid attack suspect seeks release ... Holiday movie preview Credit: Newsday

Navy honor for LI hero killed in Vietnam ... 2 charged, 2 hurt in stabbing at NCC ... National Adoption Day celebration ... Trendy Bites: Rainbow chocolate chip cookies

Loading video…

2 charged, 2 hurt in stabbing at NCC ... Acid attack suspect seeks release ... Holiday movie preview Credit: Newsday

Navy honor for LI hero killed in Vietnam ... 2 charged, 2 hurt in stabbing at NCC ... National Adoption Day celebration ... Trendy Bites: Rainbow chocolate chip cookies

Subscribe

Unlimited Digital AccessOnly 25¢for 6 months

SUBSCRIBESALE ENDS SOON | CANCEL ANYTIME