Barbara and Tim Ledogar stand in the kitchen of their...

Barbara and Tim Ledogar stand in the kitchen of their Setauket Colonial. Beyond the kitchen is the den. (July 7, 2013) Credit: Danielle Finkelstein

SELLERS. Barbara and Tim Ledogar

ADDRESS. 19 Parsonage Rd., Setauket

ASKING PRICE. $659,000

THE COMPETITION. A nearby four-bedroom, 2½-bath Colonial is listed for $599,000.

RECENT SALE IN THE AREA. A four-bedroom, 4½-bath house on Gnarled Hollow Rd. sold in mid-January for $765,000.

TAXES. $14,246

TIME ON THE MARKET. On and off since 2009

LISTING AGENT. Carol Wendell, RE/MAX Alliance, Miller Place, 631-948-1319

WHY IT'S FOR SALE. Tim, 61, and Barbara, 59, own and operate an auto repair business in Centereach. They say they are planning to retire to Florida.

The Ledogars have owned their four-bedroom 3½-bath Colonial since 1988 and raised their three now-adult sons there. The house was built in 1988 and is on a .52-acre lot. What separates this property from other Colonials in the area is the two-story barn in the backyard. Barbara talks about the home:

“There are 3 acres behind us that cannot be built on .?.?. We put in a master bedroom and master bathroom over the attached two-car garage with his-and-hers bathrooms. We upgraded the kitchen with new cabinets, countertops and appliances. We put in a stone fireplace and refinished the second-floor hardwood floors .?.?. We have a two-story, 24-by-40-foot barn that actually matches the exterior of the house. My husband builds hot rods in there. But that [space] could be whatever anybody wants it to be .?.?. We put in the in-ground pool and have Trek decking around it. The whole pool and deck area is lit. The home is in the historic district of Setauket .?.?. It’s a dead-end street so there’s no through traffic.”

Latest Videos

Newsday LogoYour Island. Your Community. Your News.Digital AccessOnly 25¢for 5 months