Album / CD art cover titled "Matthew Morrison" by Matthew...

Album / CD art cover titled "Matthew Morrison" by Matthew Morrison Credit:

As unlikely as it sounds, Broadway star-turned- "Glee"-teacher Matthew Morrison's debut "Matthew Morrison" (Mercury) could use, well, some more Matthew Morrison.

When he's at his best -- in the pop-rocker "Still Got Tonight," co-written by "American Idol" Kris Allen, and the Jason Mraz-ish, island-tinged "Hey," co-written by Morrison and 'N Sync's JC Chasez -- TV's Mr. Schue is clearly ready for broader stardom as a new adult pop leading man.

Unfortunately, even on what should be a sure thing like Morrison's debut, there's still unnecessary bet-hedging.

The weakest parts of "Matthew Morrison" are the celebrity-driven hedges. His duet with Sting on the already-corny "Let Your Soul Be Your Pilot" is leaden, while the weird mash-up of Elton John's "Mona Lisas and Mad Hatters" and "Rocket Man" is too long and kind of droning, even when Elton shows up to help out.

Even "Somewhere Over the Rainbow," which Morrison has turned into his signature after singing it on "Glee" and numerous TV appearances, can't be allowed to be only his, becoming a duet with Gwyneth Paltrow.

It's too bad, since those slots could have been replaced with sweet little surprises like the Broadway-styled ballad "It's Over," which Morrison co-wrote with Marc Shaiman, or the club-pop number "Dancing in the Rain." Luckily, Morrison's debut is good enough to give him plenty of chances to get the mix right.

 

'Matthew Morrison'

 

GRADE B

BOTTOM LINE A good, serious debut that could use some more glee

SUBSCRIBE

Unlimited Digital AccessOnly 25¢for 6 months

ACT NOWSALE ENDS SOON | CANCEL ANYTIME