Angie Zeiderman is no Lady Gaga, more Roy Orbison on 'American Idol'

Yeah, she's doing "When You've Got It, Flaunt It," from "The Producers." Voice is way high and fake, whole thing is over-the-top and has me hoping it ends faster.

Hmm, then she insists on doing another song, more normally -- Roy Orbison's "Blue Bayou." She can actually sing. It's a difficult song to do and she is totally in control. "That actually changed my mind," says Randy Jackson.

Yeah, me, too. Ditch all the crazy self-expression stuff, andjust sing! "I like her, she's like interesting," concludes Jackson.