Creighton Faker, Aaron Marcellus, Nick Boddington and Jen Hirsch blend into one on 'American Idol'

Hmmm, second part is better, start to showcase their vocals a bit. Still, compared to some of the other A-list performances tonight, this is a C for me. "Harmonies were great, solo singing was beautiful," says Steven Tyler.

They all make it, except for Boddington.

The judges then close out the first of its Las Vegas round by telling the surviving contestants that they have to make more cuts . . .