Haley Reinhart does nothing special to close out 'American Idol'

Haley Reinhart is singing "Beautiful" to close out "American Idol." She really should win the night based on the Carole King theme.

But she's so inconsistent, even though she has the confidence at this point. The performance just doesn't grab me. I'm tuning out halfway through. Nothing special here.

"I heard God in your voice," claims Steven Tyler. Jennifer Lopez just says "beautiful," and "amazing." Randy Jackson didn't love the start, but thought the end was good.