Hollie Cavanagh turns in 'beautiful and intimate' performance on 'American Idol'

It's slow, emotional and compelling -- she's such a strong vocalist. Sits on the piano the whole time; problem is not sure it'll be that memorable by the end of the night, not a song a lot of Americans know.

"I loved it, I loved it, I loved it," says Steven Tyler. "You nailed it, and I don't even know that song."

I've always liked her vocally, but she doesn't have the fan base to win this.