Lazaro Arbos redeems himself, Janelle Arthur butchers Billy Joel song on 'American Idol'
They're all living in fantasy land; Arthur was not very good, I can only conclude they're trying to talk her up so she doesn't get booted.
At any rate, it's a flat, unappealing performance -- nobody shines, tempo is off, just all around forgettable.
"Wow," says Jackson, "that was so good." My gosh, what is going on with the judges tonight, everyone but Urban's been living in happy land. Carey applauds them, literally and verbally; Urban says "you girls look great together," and leaves it at that.
Okay, good to have some reality injected back in.
Most Popular
Top Stories
Billy Joel pays tribute to Tony Bennett at NYC gala
1m read

G.E. Smith bringing Roger Waters to The Suffolk
3m read

25 years later, Howard Gordon reflects on '24'
2m read
Twisted Sister's costume designer rocks her way into LI Music and Entertainment Hall of Fame
4m read

17 Hallmark movies, specials, more must-see holiday TV treats
6m read
Rock band Zebra will tour LI this weekend with multiple appearances booked
2m read