Paige Miles kicked off 'American Idol'? Or will it be Andrew Garcia...

"American Idol" is most likely sending Paige Miles home tonight, according to the members of our expert Newsday panel -- but Andrew Garcia got a vote, too, with Tim Urban, Didi Benami and even Katie Stevens candidates for the bottom three.

After one week, last year's second-place panelist, Verne Gay, is tied for first, along with newcomer Peggy Lundquist.

Here are all our picks, below. (Scoring system: Panelists who correctly picked Lacey Brown to get the boot last week have a record of 1-0, everyone else is 0-1. You get one point for each contestant correctly predicted to be in the bottom three, with an extra point if you pick who went home.)

Verne Gay (1-0, 3 points)
-Didi Benami (going home)
-Paige Miles
-Andrew Garcia

Peggy Lundquist (1-0, 3 points)
-Paige Miles (going home)
-Andrew Garcia
-Tim Urban 

Jonathan McCarthy (0-1, 3 points)
-Paige Miles (going home)
-Tim Urban
-Didi Benami

Adam Abramson (0-1, 2 points)
-Paige Miles (going home)
-Didi Benami
-Tim Urban

Daniel Bubbeo (0-1, 2 points)
-Paige Miles (going home)
-Andrew Garcia
-Tim Urban

Glenn Gamboa (0-1, 2 points)
-Paige Miles (going home)
-Lee Dewyze
-Tim Urban

Ronnie Gill (0-1, 2 points)
-Andrew Garcia (going home)
-Paige Miles
-Tim Urban

Jamshid Mousavinezhad (0-1, 2 points)
-Paige Miles (going home)
-Andrew Garcia
-Tim Urban

Eileen Fredes (0-1, 1 point)
-Paige Miles (going home)
-Andrew Garcia
-Katie Stevens

PHOTOS: "American Idol" final round | "Idol" top 12 party with "Glee" stars

REWIND: See the winners and top finalists from each season of "American Idol"

MORE: Read all of our other "American Idol" posts

TALK: Who should be kicked off tonight? Click on "Add a comment" at the bottom of this post, or e-mail me and I'll post it for you.