Shocker: Pia Toscano in the bottom three on 'American Idol'

Paul McDonald, Pia Toscano and Scotty McCreery are up next. Obviously Paul is headed to the bottom three out of this group.

They send Scotty back to safety but nobody's fooled into thinking Pia won't be right behind him. Whoa -- but Pia's in the bottom three! No way! That is a huuuuuuge shock.

Big boos from the audience. Wow. How powerful are the votes of those teenage girls out there?!