Siobhan Magnus doesn't quite get the "Game"

Siobhan Magnus struggled with Chris Isaak’s “Wicked Game,” not on the high notes, but the low ones. She has a nice voice, but this was a bit too dreary. It's not the kind of first impression anyone would want to make, is it?

Kara says she’s a quirky girl and it feels real. Randy said she reach to bigger things. Ellen says it was a great song choice. Simon says it was too dark.