Skylar Laine sings a plain song well on 'American Idol'

This is about the only time all night they've been right -- the song just isn't that good. She sings it well because she has real skills, but except for the last line, the performance does nothing to showcase her talent.

"I just love the way you sing," says Steven Tyler. Jennifer Lopez says "you really killed that, didn't love that the song didn't have more of a chorus, but you did your thing, you did that country thing."