THE SHOW "The Show With Vinny" 
 WHEN | WHERE Premieres Thursday night at 10 on <a href="/topics//MTV">MTV</a> 
 WHAT IT'S ABOUT In a modest middle-class Cape on Staten Island, a talk show is born, starring former "<a href="/topics//Jersey_Shore_(TV_series)">Jersey Shore</a>" cast member <a href="/topics//Vinny_Guadagnino">Vinny Guadagnino</a>, as himself, along with his mother, Paola Giaimo, who cooks -- and does plenty of talking herself -- and sisters, Antonella and Mariann <a href="/topics//Vinny_Guadagnino">Guadagnino</a>. There's also a special appearance by Uncle Nino (whom we've previously met on "<a href="/topics//Jersey_Shore_(TV_series)">Jersey Shore</a>"), bearing gifts (his own blend of wine, or we think it's wine). The premiere -- previewed last month following the "<a href="/topics//MTV_Movie_Awards">MTV Movie Awards</a>" -- featured in-home interviews with Lil <a href="/topics//Lil_Wayne">Wayne</a> and <a href="/topics//YouTube">YouTube</a> comedy star Jenna Marbles. Future guests include <a href="/topics//Jenny_McCarthy">Jenny McCarthy</a>, Kat Graham, A$AP Rocky and <a href="/topics//Mark_Wahlberg">Mark Wahlberg</a>. 
 MY SAY "The Show With Vinny" is a certifiable mess. It's as if this were a talk show performed as a card trick, where the deck is tossed in the air and the cards haphazardly flutter to the ground. It's the anti-talk show, the talk show that isn't a talk show, the talk show from another planet -- that would be Staten Island -- talk show. And yet, in a weirdly unexpected way, it almost works -- and potentially could work. 
 The real stars -- the ones who caught our eye and made us laugh (or made me laugh) -- are Paola and Nino, but "The Show With Paola and Nino and Vinny" is probably too long a title, so "The Show With Vinny" will have to do. 
 As a host, Vinny needs work -- a lot of work. He laughs too hard (mostly at his own observations, or in the manner of an obsequious infomercial pitch- man). His questions are lame, incurious and star-struck. (Vinny, you have Wayne and all you can ask about is his fashion line and skateboarding skills?) 
 But there's charm here and -- you may hate me for saying this -- even some promise. Most of all, the host is very nearly likable. Now, he just has to grow a talk-show-host brain. 
 BOTTOM LINE Let's count our blessings: At least this isn't "The Show With Snooki." 
 GRADE C

THE SHOW "The Show With Vinny" WHEN | WHERE Premieres Thursday night at 10 on MTV WHAT IT'S ABOUT In a modest middle-class Cape on Staten Island, a talk show is born, starring former "Jersey Shore" cast member Vinny Guadagnino, as himself, along with his mother, Paola Giaimo, who cooks -- and does plenty of talking herself -- and sisters, Antonella and Mariann Guadagnino. There's also a special appearance by Uncle Nino (whom we've previously met on "Jersey Shore"), bearing gifts (his own blend of wine, or we think it's wine). The premiere -- previewed last month following the "MTV Movie Awards" -- featured in-home interviews with Lil Wayne and YouTube comedy star Jenna Marbles. Future guests include Jenny McCarthy, Kat Graham, A$AP Rocky and Mark Wahlberg. MY SAY "The Show With Vinny" is a certifiable mess. It's as if this were a talk show performed as a card trick, where the deck is tossed in the air and the cards haphazardly flutter to the ground. It's the anti-talk show, the talk show that isn't a talk show, the talk show from another planet -- that would be Staten Island -- talk show. And yet, in a weirdly unexpected way, it almost works -- and potentially could work. The real stars -- the ones who caught our eye and made us laugh (or made me laugh) -- are Paola and Nino, but "The Show With Paola and Nino and Vinny" is probably too long a title, so "The Show With Vinny" will have to do. As a host, Vinny needs work -- a lot of work. He laughs too hard (mostly at his own observations, or in the manner of an obsequious infomercial pitch- man). His questions are lame, incurious and star-struck. (Vinny, you have Wayne and all you can ask about is his fashion line and skateboarding skills?) But there's charm here and -- you may hate me for saying this -- even some promise. Most of all, the host is very nearly likable. Now, he just has to grow a talk-show-host brain. BOTTOM LINE Let's count our blessings: At least this isn't "The Show With Snooki." GRADE C

Entertainment

ETTEL02.WEB

'The Show With Vinny' review: Let Ma talk

Newsday

vinny cropped

Entertainment trending

Take our quizzes

50 best LI movies

AI's effect on entertainment

Jones Beach summer 2026 concerts

Most Popular

Entertainment Rail Module

The disgraced former Congressman will test his survival skills on "'Special Forces: World's Toughest Test."

George Santos to compete on Fox's 'Special Forces: World's Toughest Test'

Stern, who currently does three weekly shoes, has reportedly laid off a dozen staffers.

Report: Howard Stern to cut back SiriusXM work to 1 day a week

It feels, at its best, like the kind of Old Hollywood production that once drew millions to movie palaces.

'The Odyssey': Larger-than-life spectacle doesn't disappoint

The Grammy winner shares stories about her show at Sag Harbor, Clive Davis and more.

Melissa Manchester talks about 'Cagney,' Clive Davis, performing on LI, more

The festival returns for its 31st year with dozens of foreign films and more U.S. indie titles than usual.

What to watch at this year's Stony Brook Film Festival

Joel was interviewed by Rick Beato for his music-oriented YouTube podcast.

Billy Joel appears on Rick Beato's music podcast

Sign up for Newsday's Entertainment newsletter

Entertainment newsletter widget

More Entertainment

Entertainment Article Bottom Module

There's little new in this docuseries about the L.I. stock firm behind a major fraud,

Take two: 'Real Wolf of Wall Street' rehashes the movie

This new 'Prairie' home puts a fresher and truer spin on Laura Ingalls Wilder's stories.

Netflix's 'Little House' reboot has a big heart

Nominees "The Diplomat," "The Gilded Age" and "The Beast in Me" all have local ties.

'The Pitt,' 'Hacks' and LI-themed shows are all heavy Emmy contenders

Back in the '60s, the legendary DJ knew was what was happening on New York radio.

Rock, roll and remember: Murray the K, the 'Fifth Beatle'

Here's a look back at the movies, theater, TV and music that captivated us during that glorious year:

Remembering the pop culture of 1976: The Bicentennial year brought us 'Charlie's Angels,' 'Rocky,' 'Disco Duck,' lots more

NEWSDAY TV SHORTS

Vertical videos

An arbitrator detailed ex-officer George Trimigliozzi's poor job performance before his high-profile criminal case. NewsdayTV's Virginia Huie and Newsday investigative reporter Jim Baumbach has more.

Suffolk brothel cop repeatedly ignored emergency calls before indictment

A weaver from Huntington helped hide guns from the British at his home. NewsdayTV's Doug Geed reports.

America 250: The arsenal in Huntington

Suffolk County officials Monday warned of scammers, preying primarily on the elderly, who direct people to liquidate their life savings to buy gold bars. NewsdayTV's Virginia Huie reports.

Gold bar scam warning in Suffolk County

NewsdayTV's Doug Geed heads to a new restaurant opened by the same owners who created Westhampton Beach Brewery.

Out East: Brewery opens new restaurant

NewsdayTV's Ken Buffa visited Garcia's Taco Bar in Brentwood to try their birria ramen.

Trendy Bites: Birria ramen

NewsdayTV's Marie Elena Martinez got a sneak peek at the new Babylon Whiskey Down Diner location, which is currently under construction with plans to open in the fall.

Take a peek inside Whiskey Down Diner's new location

For a quick trip not far from home, NewsdayTV's Elisa DiStefano checks out the Rockaway Hotel.

A getaway close to home for mom

Joe Tosini, owner of River Center Shopping Center in Riverhead, said the businesses in the center lost power during Saturday's storms and that their electricity wasn't restored until late Tuesday afternoon. NewsdayTV's Shari Einhorn reports.

Riverhead shopping center back in business after 3-day power outage

NewsdayTV's Elisa DiStefano joined the volunteers of Save the Great South Bay to clean oysters. The oysters are cleaned weekly and then placed back into the bay, where they'll be able to help filter the water.

Help boost the Great South Bay oyster population

As boaters set out on the water this summer, they will be paying more at the pump. NewsdayTV's Virginia Huie reports.

Boaters feeling the pinch at the pump 

Sitewide Video Playlist

A heat advisory remains in effect on Long Island through late Thursday. NewsdayTV's meteorologist Geoff Bansen has the forecast.

Canadian wildfire smoke could impact Long Island

Vincent Puleo, who's worked in public office for nearly two decades, terminated the spa's lease following Newsday's reporting. NewsdayTV's Virginia Huie talks with Newsday reporters Sandra Peddie and Bahar Ostadan about the story.

'They dabble in other stuff behind the covers'

Police are only addressing the supply, but demand is what fuels the illicit sex trade, experts say. Newsday political reporter Bahar Ostadan has the story.

'If you don't address demand, you don't address the problem'

'He really wasn't being a police officer'

'Very thankful that we saved that money for her'

There have been 23 closures due to shark sightings at Queens' Rockaway Beach and that has other South Shore beaches on alert. NewsdayTV's Shari Einhorn has more.

'They're coming to visit more often'

DeVuono describes her scheme to an undercover investigator in January 2022.

See the undercover video of the DeVuono sting

'We're still behind'

The foundation paid for staff events at wine bars, a $2,000 limo ride and a Gracie Mansion gala. Newsday investigative reporter Peter D'auria, Richard Kessel, current chairman of the Nassau Health Care Corporation and Albany Law School professor Randle Pollard discuss.

'It should exist for the benefit of the hospital'

It was an unimaginable crime that shattered the idyllic image of a suburbia. On July 4, 1956, little Peter Weinberger, only 32 days old, was snatched out of his stroller on the back patio of his family's home in Westbury and killed. NewsdayTV's Shari Einhorn reports.

'It impacts who I am today, and I'm going to be 80'

Dangerous extreme heat with the possibility of thunderstorms are in store for Long Island and the entire NYC area beginning Wednesday, NewsdayTV's meteorologist Geoff Bansen has the forecast.

Possible record temperatures coming

Juan Bonilla Lagos, who was arrested by ICE in October near his Plainview home, was freed from jail after nine months.

'I fought so hard'

App Nativo Ad Unit Slot

TV - megaslot

Newsday TV critic Verne Gay reviews new TV shows and series from Netflix, Max, Hulu and more. Plus, what Long Island actors are working on and Long Island filming locations.

'The Show With Vinny' review: Let Ma talk

Most Popular

Top Stories

Stay logged in.