Bagel Plaza
Established in 1962, Bagel Plaza claims to be the first bagel store on Long Island's South Shore. Back then, it was poppy, sesame or salt. Now, Bagel Plaza offers forty different bagels (regular, flat, twists and minis), bialys, challahs, ruggulah, muffins and rolls made from scratch every day as well as a full line of smoked fish, 12 flavored cream cheeses, 18 cold salads and French toast, blintzes, potato pancakes, knishes and French crepes.
Bagel Plaza has a large, pleasant dining room in which to enjoy the bounty.
Most Popular
Top Stories
Inside one of LI's most exclusive clubs where members spend up to $4G ... for meat
5m read
Top pizzeria closes temporarily, just 2 months after launch
LI wedding venue getting new name, menu for 2027
1m read
Sneak peek: Inside LI's new Whiskey Down Diner location
1m read
Top Korean restaurant opens 2nd LI location
1m read
Your guide to LI farm stands: Where to find local produce, eggs and more
15m read
