Crabby Amy

Crabby Amy's Clam and Oyster bar in Seaford. Credit: Newsday photo / Thomas A. Ferrara
An informal clam bar serving breakfast, lunch and dinner until sundown. Under the same ownership as Catfish Max. Located in the Treasure Island Marina.
Breakfast: This is one of the rare dockside eateries to serve breakfast, and what a breakfast it is. I was wowed by a luxurious seafood omelet, chock-full of freshly picked crabmeat and big shrimp, the whole thing smothered in paprika-sprinkled Hollandaise sauce. Was it my imagination, or did the boat sit a little lower in the water after breakfast? --Erica Marcus
Most Popular
Top Stories

Popular LI diner opening 2nd location
1m read

Jericho banquet hall sues Oyster Bay over denied catering permit
1m read
Guide: LI's standout bacon, egg and cheese sandwiches
4m read

All-you-can-eat chain opens 3rd LI location
1m read

NYC halal spot expands to LI

For sale: New Bakaliko, full of imported gustatory treasure from Greece
4m read