Crabby Amy

Crabby Amy's Clam and Oyster bar in Seaford. Credit: Newsday photo / Thomas A. Ferrara
An informal clam bar serving breakfast, lunch and dinner until sundown. Under the same ownership as Catfish Max. Located in the Treasure Island Marina.
Breakfast: This is one of the rare dockside eateries to serve breakfast, and what a breakfast it is. I was wowed by a luxurious seafood omelet, chock-full of freshly picked crabmeat and big shrimp, the whole thing smothered in paprika-sprinkled Hollandaise sauce. Was it my imagination, or did the boat sit a little lower in the water after breakfast? --Erica Marcus
Most Popular
Top Stories

SoBoL expanding on LI with 4 new açaí bowl shops planned in 2026
2m read

Popular Huntington diner closes, for now, amid yearslong dispute with landlord
1m read

Food vendor for Hampton Classic Horse Show sues after contract dispute
2m read

Longtime pizzeria reopens after 2 years
1m read

Budget-friendly dumpling spot opens with handmade noodles
1m read

Cannoli cafe opens 2nd LI location
2m read