Marybill Diner CLOSED
Housed in a vintage 1949 Silk City diner, this venerable spot is defiantly old-fashioned and, some might say, a little worn around the edges. No matter. Owners Mary and Nick Kolkos serve the definitive Western omelet, threaded with delicate strands of onion and bursting with ham and bright peppers. Pancakes are lacy, crisp-edged, thin and tender. Service is unfailingly warm. --Joan Reminick
Most Popular
Top Stories
Inside one of LI's most exclusive clubs where members spend up to $4G ... for meat
5m read

Top pizzeria closes temporarily, just 2 months after launch

LI wedding venue getting new name, menu for 2027
1m read

Sneak peek: Inside LI's new Whiskey Down Diner location
1m read

Top Korean restaurant opens 2nd LI location
1m read

Your guide to LI farm stands: Where to find local produce, eggs and more
15m read