The 8 best seafood restaurants on Long Island: Eat here now

Soft-shell crab at The Jolly Fisherman. Credit: Newsday / Erica Marcus
Each year, you expect Long Island to overflow with outstanding seafood restaurants. But that doesn't happen. You put up with more limp fried calamari and overcooked farmed fish than anyone should before finding perfect Peconic Bay scallops and pristine striped bass, incomparable Montauk tuna and briny-sweet local oysters.
These 8 restaurants, listed alphabetically, always deliver the big catch.
Most Popular
Top Stories

Ice cream shop opens with more than 35 'extravagant' flavors
1m read

Is LI's new members-only dining club worth $5,000, plus $1,200 a year? You decide.
2m read

Dockside clam shack closes after fire
1m read

Ambitious (but tiny) wine bar opens with star chef
2m read

Top LI pizzeria opens second location
1m read

Top LI pizzerias prep for proposed ban on common ingredient used in dough
4m read