Wahlburgers, the burger joint at the heart of a reality TV show, is not the same in real life.

Credit: Daniel Brennan

The O.F.D. (Originally From Dorchestah) at Wahlburgers in Port Jefferson Station is a half-pound burger paired with Swiss cheese, bacon, sauteed mushrooms and housemade tomato jam.

Credit: Daniel Brennan

The Wahlburgers in Port Jefferson Station opened in 2016.

Credit: Daniel Brennan

From left, Jessica DePrina, Angus Micheline, Nikki McCabe, Dan Walsh, and Joey Faller, all of Port Jefferson Station, dine in a booth at Wahlburgers in Port Jefferson Station.

Credit: Daniel Brennan

The sunken bar at Wahlburgers in Port Jefferson Station features 30 beers on tap, including several quality pints brewed on Long Island.

Credit: Daniel Brennan

A mural-sized photo of the Wahlberg brothers and their mother hangs on the wall of the dining room at Wahlburgers in Port Jefferson Station.

Credit: Daniel Brennan

The bun is replaced with thick-cut, butter-grilled toast for the Melt at Wahlburgers in Port Jefferson Station, a third-pound burger that's topped with “government” (American) cheese, bacon, caramelized onions, pickles and mustard sauce.

Credit: Daniel Brennan

Tater tots and sweet potato tater tots are two of the sides at Wahlburgers in Port Jefferson Station.

Credit: Newsday/Pervaiz Shallwani

A nest of crispy, thin onion rings at Wahlburgers in Port Jefferson Station.

Credit: Daniel Brennan

Any burger or sandwich at Wahlburgers in Port Jefferson Station can be de-bunned and transformed into a salad. Here, Jenn's Chicken Sandwich, made with seared chicken breast, is tossed with greens and caramelized onions, and topped with crispy onions and a house-made honey-garlic mayo.

Credit: Daniel Brennan

Mom's Sloppy Joe is an open-faced sandwich on thick slices of bread covered with housemade sloppy joe and topped with fried onions and Paul's signature Wahl sauce, served at Wahlburgers in Port Jefferson Station.

Credit: Daniel Brennan

Thick frappes, Boston slang for a milkshake, are spun to order at Wahlburgers in Port Jefferson Station.

 
SUBSCRIBE

Unlimited Digital AccessOnly 25¢for 6 months

ACT NOWSALE ENDS SOON | CANCEL ANYTIME