Jor'Dynn Duncan case: Court filings reveal chilling messages sent months before 7-year-old girl died

An undated photograph of Jor'Dynn Duncan. Credit: Alisha Crystal Case
The 24-year-old Bayport woman charged with the unlawful imprisonment of Jor’Dynn Duncan expressed regret for her treatment of the child in text messages six months before the 7-year-old girl died, prosecutors alleged in a recent court filing.
Elyssa Seymore, who is also facing two counts of endangering the welfare of a child, told her mother “god got something for me” in a June 14, 2025 message discovered by investigators.
“That was crazy of me to do to a kid tho (sic),” Seymore wrote to her mother, Emily Kelly, who is charged with depraved indifference murder in the girl’s Dec. 29 death. “I hate this [expletive]. Nobody hurts kids and she [Jor'Dynn] made me do it.”
The messages were revealed as prosecutors asked a Suffolk judge to deny Seymore’s request to have her charges dismissed. Both women, and Kelly’s mother, Barbara Renner, who is facing a top charge of manslaughter, are due to appear before State Supreme Court Justice John Collins in Riverhead Thursday as they seek pretrial relief.
WHAT NEWSDAY FOUND
- Prosecutors have shared messages showing 24-year-old Elyssa Seymore expressing concerns to her mother, Emily Kelly, about allegedly harming 7-year-old Jor’Dynn Duncan six months before the child’s death.
- Seymore also threatened to beat the girl again and worried neighbors would hear the abuse and report them to police, according to the messages revealed in a recent court filing.
- Jor’Dynn died on Dec. 29 from an infection caused by sharp-force injuries.

Elyssa Seymore is facing first-degree unlawful imprisonment and two counts of endangering the welfare of a child charges in connection with Jor'Dynn Duncan's death. Credit: SCDA
In another series of messages allegedly sent in August 2025, Seymore threatened to beat Jor’Dynn with a shoe “again,” saying her own nails are “too long.” She also expressed worry that the loud alleged beatings might lead neighbors to call the police.
“They will take [my son] away,” prosecutors allege Seymore wrote. “… we all will be charged with child endangerment.”
Kelly justified the alleged abuse in response to her daughter’s concerns.
“Don’t,” she wrote when Seymore said she was “feeling really bad for what I did.”
“Wrestling with the devil every night,” Kelly said of the 7-year-old.
Jor'Dynn was pronounced dead at NYU Langone Hospital-Suffolk in Patchogue at 11:47 a.m. on Dec. 29, roughly 75 minutes after Kelly and Renner first called 911 to report the child’s illness, court records show.
An autopsy performed two days later by Suffolk County Medical Examiner Dr. Odette Hall determined Jor'Dynn had a perforated bowel and infected peritoneal cavity, injuries that were just days old at the time of her death. There were nine sharp-force injuries "clustered in and around the anus," including a four-inch wound inside the anus that led to the perforated bowel and infection, according to the filing.
Kelly, Renner and Seymore were arrested May 20 following an extensive law enforcement investigation. Prosecutors have said the first allegations of abuse were reported by Jor’Dynn to Bayport-Blue Point school officials as early as January and Jor’Dynn missed more than 11 full weeks of school in her year living with the women in Bayport.
Kelly, who was engaged to Jor’Dynn’s father, Derrick Dixon, was granted custody of the girl in April 2025 while he was serving a sentence in upstate Sing Sing Correctional Facility.

Emily Kelly, 50, left, Barbara Renner, 75, and Elyssa Seymore, 24, have been charged in connection with the death of 7-year-old Jor'Dynn Duncan. Credit: SCDA
The women have all pleaded not guilty in criminal court and blamed the second-grader's injuries on self-harm, which attorneys for Kelly have argued began after the child lost contact with her biological mother. Civil attorneys for biological mother Portia Duncan have filed a $250 million federal lawsuit in the Eastern District of New York against Suffolk County and the Bayport-Blue Point Union Free School District, as well as individual county Child Protective Services workers and school officials.
Attorney Katherine Fernandez, who is representing Seymore in the criminal case, filed a motion last month arguing that the evidence presented to the grand jury was not legally sufficient to support the charges against her client, who she said had no duty to care for Jor’Dynn, records show. Fernandez is also seeking to suppress statements her client made to police.
Assistant District Attorney Melissa Grier countered in an Oct. 30 response that from Aug. 12 through Aug. 15, 2025 Seymore kept Jor’Dynn in an area where she was “subjected to the risk of serious physical injury."
Prosecutors have alleged that video evidence from those dates showed Jor’Dynn was kept unclothed in a bathtub of the home. In one video she has what appears to be socks covering her hands.
In a text message exchange between Seymore and Kelly on Aug. 15, 2025, Seymore told her mother Jor’Dynn could not stand because she was “tied up,” court records show.
Fernandez declined to comment on the filings when contacted Tuesday.
October's LI home prices are out ... LIRR's Thanksgiving expanded service ... Suffolk police vehicle auction ... What's in store with the weather
October's LI home prices are out ... LIRR's Thanksgiving expanded service ... Suffolk police vehicle auction ... What's in store with the weather


