Matthew Papile, 18, was sentenced to 6 to up to 18...

Matthew Papile, 18, was sentenced to 6 to up to 18 years in prison on Thursday. Credit: Rick Kopstein

A Port Jefferson teenager, who crashed into and killed a Lake Grove great-grandmother as he drove a stolen Land-Rover high on marijuana while speeding and livestreaming on Instagram, has left a path of "pain and destruction" that will endure for a lifetime, the victim's daughter said Thursday as the young motorist was sentenced to up to 18 years in prison.

The May 4, 2024 crash in Centereach killed 73-year-old Marion Napolitano and left her adult son, James Miller, with traumatic brain injuries that he struggles with to this day, said Carrie Sabatino, the victim's daughter said in court in Central Islip.

Matthew Papile, 16 at the time of the crash, pleaded guilty in September to aggravated vehicular homicide, second-degree manslaughter, aggravated vehicular assault, second-degree assault, leaving the scene of an incident resulting in a death, third-degree criminal possession of stolen property and driving while impaired by drugs.

"The trauma is unreal," Sabatino said in a statement read by Assistant District Attorney Raymond Varuolo. "I am currently in therapy. I feel robbed of seeing my mother and saying goodbye. She was supposed to grow old with us; holding our hand and peacefully pass. I cannot imagine the terror she felt in those last moments of her life."

Papile, now 18, stood handcuffed as Acting State Supreme Court Justice Karen Kerr dismissed requests from the defense to consider sentencing the defendant as a youthful offender, citing the seriousness of his behavior and past runs-in with the law for theft, fights and drug use.

"The impact of this crime extends far beyond the collision, and the consequences of your actions will be felt by this family every day for the rest of their lives," Kerr said as she sentenced Papile to 6 to 18 years in prison on the top count.

Papile, in a statement read by Sean Dixon, his defense attorney, expressed remorse.

"I am sorry and remorseful for my actions," he said." I think about them every day and how I could have prevented it from that. I was young and didn't think of the risk at the time. I am truly sorry for that which was lost, and for I promise that when I get another chance in society, I will be more careful and a better person."

Family members for both the victims and the defendant teared up in court as the sentence was read. Both sides declined to speak to Newsday after the sentencing.

On the evening of the crash, Papile was driving a blue 2008 Land-Rover LR2 that authorities said he stole from a driveway in Coram.

Shortly after 9 p.m., Papile, impaired on marijuana while streaming on his Instagram account, drove the SUV eastbound on Middle Country Road at a high rate of speed, while weaving in and out of traffic, prosecutors said.

Papile first struck the side of one vehicle, fleeing the scene while continuing to drive recklessly, weaving across the eastbound lanes and cutting off other vehicles, prosecutors said.

The teen the slammed into the rear of a 1994 Toyota Corolla driven by Napolitano, sending it off the road and into a telephone pole and a tree, authorities said.

The stolen Land-Rover, prosecutors said, spun out of control and came to rest in the center lane of travel.

Papile ran from the scene but was quickly apprehended by three good Samaritans, including an off-duty Suffolk County police officer, who held him until officers arrived, officials said.

Napolitano was taken to Stony Brook University Hospital where she was pronounced dead. Miller, 50, a passenger in the Toyota, survived but suffered a traumatic brain injury.

"This defendant’s decision to drive while impaired in a stolen car, while livestreaming his recklessness, is indefensible," said Suffolk District Attorney Raymond Tierney. "A woman lost her life and another victim suffered a traumatic brain injury as a direct result of Matthew Papile’s actions."


 

Loading video…

Previewing Jets/Chargers game ... What's up on LI ... Picture This: 100 years of Macy's Parade Credit: Newsday

Tackling cleaner drinking water in Nassau ... MTA eying fare hikes ... Big changes at Green Acres Mall ... Previewing Jets/Chargers game

Loading video…

Previewing Jets/Chargers game ... What's up on LI ... Picture This: 100 years of Macy's Parade Credit: Newsday

Tackling cleaner drinking water in Nassau ... MTA eying fare hikes ... Big changes at Green Acres Mall ... Previewing Jets/Chargers game