Alton Harrell, of Bellport, pleaded guilty to rape and kidnapping charges.

Alton Harrell, of Bellport, pleaded guilty to rape and kidnapping charges. Credit: Suffolk County Sheriff

The Bellport man accused of picking up a 14-year-old Long Island girl at the start of her weekslong disappearance in December 2024 has pleaded guilty to rape and kidnapping charges, court records show.

Alton Harrell, 37, will be sentenced to 18 years in state prison for second-degree kidnapping under an agreement with prosecutors, according to a transcript of the proceeding.

Prosecutors said the plea deal will spare the victim from “having to relive” the abuse suffered at the hands of Harrell, who admitted Tuesday to having sex with the girl and providing her with drugs on multiple occasions despite knowing she was underage.

Assistant District Attorney Dana Castaldo called the girl, who Newsday is not naming because she is a minor and the victim of sex crimes, “exceptionally vulnerable.”

WHAT NEWSDAY FOUND

  • A Bellport man accused of picking up a 14-year-old Long Island girl at the start of her weekslong disappearance in December 2024 pleaded guilty on Tuesday to rape and kidnapping charges, court records show.
  • Alton Harrell will be sentenced to 18 years in state prison for second-degree kidnapping under an agreement with prosecutors, according to a transcript of the proceeding.
  • Harrell had been facing the possibility of serving up to life in prison if convicted of first-degree kidnapping at trial.

“We do believe it is in her best interest to avoid her having to testify here with respect to the allegations against this defendant,” the prosecutor told acting Supreme Court Justice Karen Wilutis during the proceeding in Riverhead Tuesday.

Harrell had been facing the possibility of serving up to life in prison if convicted of first-degree kidnapping at trial.

Defense attorney Jeremy Scileppi, of Commack, told the judge the agreement was reached after he met with his client before the start of a scheduled pretrial hearing Tuesday morning. They had previously rejected an offer of 15-years-to-life in prison.

“He is of a mind that ththat way to resolve the case against him,” Scileppi told the judge.

The defense attorney declined to offer additional comment following the plea.

Prosecutors have said the girl’s 25-day ordeal began on Dec. 9, 2024, after she contacted Harrell, whom she had known since January.

Under questioning from Castaldo Tuesday, Harrell admitteadmittedg the girl when she was just 13 years old in January 2024 and that she told him at the time she was 14. Despite that, Harrell confirmed that he picked the girl up at her father’s house in Patchogue that month and took her to a waterfront parking lot in Bellport, where he had sex with her and gave her crack cocaine.

Harrell also admitteadmitteding to the home at 5 p.m. on the night she disappeared. He testified that the girl was not wearing shoes or a coat and that she had a GPS monitoring bracelet she cut off while in his car. He admitteadmittedng her to an empty house in Bellport, where he had sex with her on an air mattress, before leaving her there alone the following day after they came up with a plan for him to sell her jewelry for crack cocaine.

The girl left the house while Harrell was gone and was taken by another man to a motel in Bohemia.

Castaldo said at Harrell’s February 2025 arraignment that his actions in the first 24 hours of the girl’s disappearance “set the entire chain of events that followed in motion.”

At least seven other men were accused of raping the girl during her weekslong disappearance, including Francis Buckheit, the owner of a yacht docked in Islip where the victim was discovered by her father on Jan. 3, 2025. The girl told police she stayed on the vessel with Buckheit for about three weeks.

Harrell admitted Tuesday to initially telling police he did not know where the girl was as they questioned him several times while she was still missing.

In total, nine men and two women were indicted on kidnapping, rape, drug and child sex trafficking charges related to the girl’s disappearance. Six defendants, including Buckheit, still face the possibility of going to trial on the indictment next year.

Prosecutors have said Harrell had no relationship with any other defendants in the case and is the only defendant who knew the girl before her disappearance.

Sentencing was set for Jan. 14, 2027.

What's in store with the weather ... The hottest gifts for 2026 ... AI giving young basketball players a boost Credit: Newsday

October's LI home prices are out ... LIRR's Thanksgiving expanded service ... Suffolk police vehicle auction ... What's in store with the weather

What's in store with the weather ... The hottest gifts for 2026 ... AI giving young basketball players a boost Credit: Newsday

October's LI home prices are out ... LIRR's Thanksgiving expanded service ... Suffolk police vehicle auction ... What's in store with the weather

Subscribe

Unlimited Digital AccessOnly 25¢for 6 months

SUBSCRIBESALE ENDS SOON | CANCEL ANYTIME